3 ms·
> This article disproves its own thesis. I wouldn’t be so quick to be defensive here. While it’s true that networks and drives are faster, it’s also true that
by acdha 4y ago
> This article disproves its own thesis.
I wouldn’t be so quick to be defensive here. While it’s true that networks and drives are faster, it’s also true that the metric affecting the user experience in question is time to load rather than bits per second and many modern games are much worse on that front compared to a Nintendo which was playable in about the same time it took a CRT monitor to boot up.
A more thoughtful criticism would be thinking about how gaming companies could offer the things people want (high resolution imagery, for example) with more care for the user experience - e.g. downloading in the background or after someone’s done for the night, optimizing their file structures so a small change doesn’t force most of the assets to be retransferred, telling you whether an update fixes a critical bug or can be deferred, etc. If you simplt attack people for accurately criticizing something you like, you miss out on a chance for it to be even better.
- root_axis 4y ago> it’s also true that the metric affecting the user experience in question is time to load rather than bits per second That's the metric the author has cherry-picked, and I acknowledged their legitimate frustration, but my point is that this frustration is one isolated facet of massive technological progress. I will emphatically agree that companies have leveraged improvements in technology to encroach on their customers in increasingly frustrating ways, but I disagree that this means technology is worse.
- acdha 4y agoI don’t think defining “time to play” is an unfair metric to judge a gaming system on, and it’s certainly not isolated.
- root_axis 4y agoAgain, it's not "unfair", it's myopic cherry-picking. It's also wrong to label the time it takes to download a 20gig patch "time to play", an honest accounting would recognize that "time to play" is typically a couple seconds.
- acdha 4y agoIf you go to start the game and it blocks you on an update, it counts in time to play. Consider why every holiday gift guide tells parents to put their kids new console online the night before Christmas so it can patch and ask whether it’s really unfair.