I think in the end, most people just want to have their abilities evaluated fairly. And even if I'm not a total puzzle freak, I do love to code, and given time

I think in the end, most people just want to have their abilities evaluated fairly. And even if I'm not a total puzzle freak, I do love to code, and given time I can figure most of these puzzles out. So if I were looking for a job at your (former) company, this would not constitute a barrier for me. On the other hand, if I were verbally asked a question and told to work it out on a whiteboard, this would not be an accurate indicator of my abilities or my potential. Add to that the fact that my handwriting is poor, and I would be nervous, and I'm quite sure a verbal description of pascal's triangle would almost certainly elude me, whereas if I were shown a document with the written output, I think I could come up with a naive solution in 5-10 mins. I'm good at sitting down by myself with a written problem and working it out. As a result, I've always done well on standardized tests. In fact, I suspect this is the reason for some of the indignation at the whiteboard testing. People who have always gotten good grades, coded well, done well on standardized tests are suddenly told that they're not smart enough. I can understand how it would rankle. Note: edited typos.