3 ms·
Why isn’t the slit material edge itself a detector since it must be interacting with the photon?
by mensetmanusman 4y ago
Why isn’t the slit material edge itself a detector since it must be interacting with the photon?
- lazide 4y agoPhotons that interact with the edge go through a different process of absorption and re-emission + scattering (or not). They aren't the original photon.
- mensetmanusman 4y agoThat’s true of the air the photon is traveling through though…
- lazide 4y agoAnd many of these experiments are performed in vacuum for that reason.
- mensetmanusman 4y agoThe photon double slit is not usually in a vacuum…
- lazide 4y agoPhoton true, but electron always. Photon also works the same in a vacuum though, and has been verified as such.
- OkayPhysicist 4y agoIMO, detection/observation is the wrong framing of the problem. A better approach is about consistency. All interactions in a system must be consistent: if you have two Schrodinger's cat-boxes being controlled by the same measurement, then either both cats will be dead, or both will be alive, you will never find one dead and the other alive. In an experimental setup, you might have many different levels of interaction: the photon either hits one sensor or another, that results in one or another message being sent to your recording device, which records one or the other result on your harddrive, etc. As the scale goes up, more and more stuff gets dependent on the result of your measurement, until eventually everything is, yourself included. And if everything is dependent on the result of your experiment, they must all be consistent with a given result of your experiment. Thus, you end up with exactly one answer. Since the slit edge isn't changed by the diffraction of light, there is no inconsistency between whether the photon passed through its slit or the other.
- int_19h 4y agoIt is a detector, as is the wall. But you still don't know the state of that detector until you observe it, so now the photon+detector system is itself in superposition as far as you're concerned. (And if you observe it, but nobody else observes you, then you are in a superposition as far as the rest of the world is concerned.)
- Strilanc 4y agoActually... it is! You can think of the barrier with two slits as a device that measures (a) whether the photon hit the barrier or missed barrier and additionally (b) when the photon hits the barrier, where did it hit the barrier. Notably, if the photon misses the barrier, it doesn't tell you where it missed. This is why, when the photon doesn't hit the barrier, it can end up in a superposition of passing through both slits. There's some classic thought experiment, I think it's [1], thinking about an atom decaying into a superposition expanding in a spherical shape, and how you can make barriers to shape the outgoing superposition. For example, to make an expanding half sphere, block off the other half sphere and focus on the times the decay didn't hit the barrier. 1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Renninger_negative-result_experiment#Renninger's_negative-result_experiment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Renninger_negative-result_expe...