5 ms·
Simplicity isn't a measure of quality. I have a "pro" $800 espresso machine with lots of fancy functions that is used many times a day and has been working perf
by paxys 4y ago
Simplicity isn't a measure of quality. I have a "pro" $800 espresso machine with lots of fancy functions that is used many times a day and has been working perfectly with near zero maintenance for >10 years now. I can guarantee that the author's simple $12 drip coffee maker from Amazon is going to the landfill well before that.
The problem really is that brands like Keurig are packaging these same $12 machines for $100-150, and add useless half-baked features to justify the price. Same can be said for plenty of other companies that built a reputation for quality 20+ years ago and are now trading that for a quick buck by cutting costs and sacrificing product quality. It's ultimately up to the consumer to be diligent and do their research before buying. Plenty of companies are making solid coffee machines today – Breville, Bonavita, Baratza, Gaggia, La Marzocco, Ninja, Bialetti, OXO.
- JimtheCoder 4y ago"I have a "pro" $800 espresso machine " Sorry, but just had to chuckle to myself a little...
- lapetitejort 4y agoNot sure if you're laughing at how cheap or expensive it is. Your local independent coffee shop might be sporting a five figure espresso machine. Equipment gets expensive when it needs to run >8 hours straight
- JimtheCoder 4y agoCheap...
- OJFord 4y agoThe quotes around 'pro' were as written though right, I read OP as saying 'this thing was sold to the home user as 'pro', it's expensive for the market'. I don't think someone quoting their own 'pro' is under any disillusions about how much it's used in a commercial setting... I have a Rancilio Silvia that was I think £400 (so, uh, about $400..) and it's a good thing I don't run an espresso bar. The queue out of the door would only ever shrink by people giving up and leaving. For me, it's great, but a machine that needs to make however many shots an hour all day, and peak at say 10x that, is just in a different class. Not even necessarily 'better', it just has different/extra problems to solve which would be engineering gone to waste at home; tank capacity never used, reliability never called upon.
- 0x457 4y ago$800 is far from "pro". It's not "cheap", but it also not expensive. That's just about entry level if we're taking decent machines that will last. Pro would probably start at 5k (Ascaso Baby T Plus). Commercial, that's 10k (La Marzocco Linea 2 Group EE ). Buf if we are talking about actually coffee shop, that's 20k at least.
- TheHappyOddish 4y ago"Pro" here would be "prosumer", rather than "professional".
- 10u152 4y agoApple changed the meaning of “pro” to mean “slightly higher than basic spec”
- xenadu02 4y agoIn written US English (especially online) the double quotes around "pro" imply sarcasm or that the word is not meant to be taken literally. In context it means the author knows it isn't actually a professional machine despite the manufacturer marketing it as such.
- r00fus 4y agoI used to have one of those (notably probably cheaper than yours) but the cleaning/maintenance was cumbersome and I never got around to spending the 2h/mo it would require.
- munificent 4y ago> I can guarantee that the author's simple $12 drip coffee maker from Amazon is going to the landfill well before that. I'm nearing a decade into my $15 Mr. Coffee and the little guy is still trucking along just fine. Simplicity isn't a measure of quality, but the more complex a thing is, the greater the number of parts that can fail, so it's easier to make a robust simple thing than a robust complex thing.
- verall 4y agoThrowing my hat in for the cheap Mr. Coffee It's probably my highest consumption of plastics per day based on it's "boil water in a cheap plastic container" design but it turns out if you buy simple things and use them simply they do tend to work for quite a while. I love my Roborock but I'm not going to freak out when it bites the dust in a couple years +/-
- pessimizer 4y ago> I can guarantee that the author's simple $12 drip coffee maker from Amazon is going to the landfill well before that. What makes you think you know this?
- paxys 4y agoTo start, the kind of plastic likely used in a machine at that price point will start to degrade well before 10-15 years of use. The plug/adapter/circuit board won't have adequate protection against voltage fluctuations or surges. The heating element they use will be rated for fewer cycles than their pricier counterparts. "You get what you pay for" applies for any product, especially a reasonably complex electronic one.
- zemvpferreira 4y agoWhile I have no doubt your machine can make much better coffee than a $12 plastic gizmo, the gizmo will probably outlast it. There's just less of it to fail. Durability and excellence can often be orthogonal. (Fellow coffe enthusiast and mechanical/product engineer here)
- roflyear 4y agoNah. There is basically nothing that can fail in my $800 lever espresso machine. If the boiler cracks or something insane I'll just solder it with $8 silver solder from home Depot. It's already 30 years old.
- netfortius 4y agoAbsolutely this, but I cannot blame the OP, as you can tell this is another US biased coffee making & consuming experience. The best these people may have tried, and failed to ever reach and enjoy the true quality, having - indeed - some complexity behind it, is in visiting Starbucks. On the other hand - if you visit a serious place in Europe (recommend Italy, or France), for example, try a true expresso, made with a true machine, with proper grains ground to the proper size and all other necessary conditions (water, temperature, etc.), then you'd ask yourself how you could have ever considered coffee anything else than a worthy experience, like the French cuisine. Then you save and invest into a proper machine and grinder, and forget the Mr. Coffee monstrosity having ever inflicted your senses. Even without the investment in a high end machine, an expresso setup in the price ranges above, with Yirgacheffe grains freshly ground, brings the joy of a coffee to a "place" that a morning with such gives the rest of the day another level of "joie de vivre" Same with "complex" software ...
- ativzzz 4y agounfortunately espresso lasts all of 30 seconds and while it tastes great, i make coffee while working to last longer and "keep me company" for some amount of time - espresso simply doesn't do that
- Mixtape 4y ago> The best these people may have tried, and failed to ever reach and enjoy the true quality, having - indeed - some complexity behind it, is in visiting Starbucks. This is a tangent from OPs point, but I would push back on this idea slightly. To be clear, there is absolutely a large number of people in the US who use coffee as a tool more than an experience and treat it as such. A frightening majority will shell out a few bucks on the daily for coffee from gas stations or chain restaurants, all of which will serve you the sort of over sweetened, watered-down coffee experience you'd expect in the US. However, I'm of the belief that there are undercurrents of a strong coffee culture in the states as long as you're willing to look for it. I recently took a trip along the east coast and, while searching for souvenirs, found a bag of locally roasted beans that I decided to take home. They weren't necessarily my favorite roast that I've tried, but the fact of the matter was that I was able to taste a local cultural staple and identify what made it unique for relatively low effort. Likewise, there are a growing number of locally owned and run coffee shops popping up across the country using machines similar to those you described above (my local favorite uses a Slayer [1]). The Starbucks-ification of coffee and inflation have unfortunately normalized $5 16oz house blends at many of these places, but the experience is still far more authentic and feels like a deliberate choice rather than a passive act. I apologize in advance for taking a "not all Americans" stance on this, but coffee is something that I'm genuinely passionate about despite living somewhere that tries not to be. I want other people who care to share these experiences too, but many just assume that every stateside coffee shop is the same. Hopefully this will help illuminate some other options. [1] https://slayerespresso.com/ https://slayerespresso.com/