4 ms·
I am not unsympathetic to your ultimate meaning. However... Take everyone's favorite whipping boy, Facebook/Meta, as the example corporation. At every turn, th
by dylan604 4y ago
I am not unsympathetic to your ultimate meaning. However...
Take everyone's favorite whipping boy, Facebook/Meta, as the example corporation. At every turn, they have shown that they have prioritized greed vs community good. Any good they provide is only to further their pursuit of wanting more. Because they are so large, any upstart competitor with a total opposite ethos that might come about gets annihilated by the behemoth.
If legal action were to give Meta the corporate death sentence preventing the company from operating and its execs from pivoting to somewhere else, then and only then could the competitors actually have a chance. So just because there's a death sentence for a corp doesn't mean the "people" lose as well.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> legal action were to give Meta the corporate death sentence preventing the company from operating and its execs from pivoting to somewhere else Just do the second bit. The problem with judicial dissolution is corporations are a legal fiction. What you do with the people and assets is far, far more important. Ignoring the legal fiction to focus on those is my point. Take their stuff (fines). Force them to restructure (break-up). Limit their scope (corporate criminal penalties). Restrict their executives. “Corporate death penalty” is exactly non-specific enough to avoid specifying those prescriptions.
- dylan604 4y agoyes, but in coversation, are you going to list out those things every single time like that or are you going to do it once and then follow up with, "you know, the corporate death penalty?" i don't think it's nearly as non-specific as you think. if you ask people what a corp death penalty would be, my assumption would be that people would think of it as the corporation no longer existing. if you're saying that corps would just spin off assets as a new name, new corp charter, same people, same processes, then yes, that would be a valid concern. but we can at least state that once, and all agree upon it rather than continuing to repeat it like we're unable to understand the concept.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> ask people what a corp death penalty would be, my assumption would be that people would think of it as the corporation no longer existing I mean, look at this thread. I’m not saying the impulse is wrong. But “corporate death penalty” seems to be a good way to take a discussion which could lead to an outcome into one that won’t. That’s fine! People vent! But we shouldn’t confuse venting with deliberating.
- dylan604 4y agoI just can't wrap my head around what your issue is here. Only lawyers talk like this. Are you a lawyer? People feel a corporation has committed such wrong doing that they should no longer exist. When that happens as an individual, it is known as the death penalty. Applying that same phrasing to a corporation comes with the same understanding. You're pedantry in this case are quite trite
- kelnos 4y agoNot the person you're replying to, but I think the issue is that the individual vs. corporation analogy doesn't work. If you kill a person who has done bad things, you will indeed prevent that person from doing bad things in the future. If you kill a corporation (via legally dissolving its charter, the "corporate death penalty"), then you will not keep the individuals and investors associated with that corporation from doing bad things, as they will likely reorganize into a new entity and continue to do those bad things. I agree that there's an element of pedantry there, so if (as the GP suggested), someone is just venting and doesn't care about a specific outcome, saying "give them the corporate death penalty" is fine. But the downside is that if someone reads that, and looks up legal corporate dissolution, they might get the wrong idea that this sort of remedy will actually fix the problem. Or they might not even do any research, and just decide to start throwing around this term themselves, without really understanding what it means or what it does (and doesn't) accomplish. But I also agree that listing out other specific remedies (market-cap-sized fine, jailing executives, whatever) is long-winded and annoying, and maybe not really useful or relevant unless the discussion is actually about what specific remedies might be effective.