4 ms·
Risk can be fun. I don't feel bad if someone gets hurt or killed doing an activity that is inherently dangerous. They died doing what they enjoyed and feeling a
by giantg2 4y ago
Risk can be fun. I don't feel bad if someone gets hurt or killed doing an activity that is inherently dangerous. They died doing what they enjoyed and feeling alive. Don't feel bad for me if I go that way either.
- Waterluvian 4y agoI think it's basically an "informed consent" thing. If people are clearly informed and consciously aware of the risk, that's completely up to them (eg. free solo climbers). Where it gets tricky, in my opinion is: - we aren't convinced the person is currently capable of making rational decisions - we aren't convinced the person is fully informed and equipped with an intimate understanding of the risk they're undertaking I think both of these cases are about wanting what's best for the individual, but struggling with the balance of support vs. control.
- giantg2 4y agoI'm not sure how we could enumerate all the possible risks in a wilderness or near wilderness setting.
- michaelt 4y agoNo, but you can know that A people out of 100,000 have died doing B making it less dangerous than C, more dangerous than D and 100x as dangerous as E and so on.
- giantg2 4y agoThat might actually false confidence. For example, some activities might be comprised of more skilled people driving down the fatality rate. But another activity might have fewer or more manageable risks for unskilled people but have a higher fatality rate because more unskilled people do them.
- optimalsolver 4y agoVery relevant XKCD: https://xkcd.com/795/ https://xkcd.com/795/
- TheCleric 4y agoYou don't have to enumerate, just acknowledge. Some people think trying to get a selfie with a buffalo is a good idea. You don't have to tell them all the was it could end badly, just that it likely will. Same for the person hiking something like Zion. They should be prepared for any relatively expected contingency, and if they don't know what those are, they are unprepared to do so.
- giantg2 4y agoThe picture thing is such a small part. You'd have to also do that for everything else - bear defense/prevention, hot springs, numerous injuries, etc. And you'll still have people who go "I was trying to take a picture with an elk, not a buffalo!".
- ip26 4y agoIn many incidents, people are completely misinformed on the degree of risk, or woefully unprepared, which does strike me as tragic. E.g. happy family who takes a pleasant hike a few miles from the car, except they weren’t thinking about the fact it was August in Utah and they only brought 8oz of water. It’s also evident in her story about getting caught by the river. She thought, I’m not going to do anything crazy like those climbers- and then did something that seemed innocent but was actually far more dangerous.
- giantg2 4y agoI think she had fair warning. The story states that the ranger told her that statistically one of them would die that summer. Sure they didn't enumerate all the possible dangers, but who could? It's a wilderness or near wilderness setting with innumerable risks and scenarios. Simply saying it's so dangerous that one of you should die this summer should be sufficient for someone to then do their own research and take precautions given that the total risks of the area can't be covered.
- ip26 4y agoShe was young and assumed it was the mountain climbers who were at risk. Is that her own fault? Yes. Would it still be tragic if youthful hubris & ignorance took her life in a senseless accident? Also yes.
- giantg2 4y agoI mean, if you want to be technical, anything involving death is tragic. That doesn't also mean I that I feel sorry or sad for them.
- toss1 4y agoYes, risk can be fun. But everyone I encountered in risk sports knew the difference between "smart crazy" vs "dumb crazy". It is the difference between using knowledge, skill, technology, and mental focus to reduce risk to manageable levels, vs "getting away with it". Getting away with it, riding on PDL — Pure Dumb Luck — can work for a long time. Until it doesn't, and you're dead. Like those YouTube idiots in the article. Getting away with it is just Russian Roulette with a different name and method. Yet by using knowledge, skill, technology, and mental focus, people can live entire careers in situations that would reliably kill us in seconds, everythign from mountaineering, deep underwater, aviation, space, racecar driving, and more. Understand the risks, the skills to avoid them, the technology to minimize them, and pay attention, and you'll likely be rewarded with a lifetime of risky and rewarding adventures. Read the books, take the lessons, get some good coaching and apprenticing, and don't cheap out on good gear (as they say, if you've got only a $10 head, then fine, get a $10 helmet, otherwise...). Also, listen to your body and the surroundings. If the conditions or your body is off, you don't have to TODAY climb that route, do that dive, whatever; you can do it or another one tomorrow. It is no less joy to be wise about it!
- giantg2 4y agoIn my experience, some people operate on PDL because they never learned about risk in general, or are incapable of operating differently. If you get hurt as a kid in a lower stakes fashion, you start to learn that breaking the rules hurts. That opportunity for lower stakes learning might be shrinking as we legislate away some "risky" stuff. Some people simply can't handle the "constraints" of being responsible... like my wife. Her favorite quote is "I just want to live life". No thoughts to "what if?" or being prepared. If some stranger held the same beliefs and died, I still wouldn't feel bad - that's the way they chose to live thier life.
- toss1 4y ago>>operate on PDL because they never learned about risk in general Yup, humans are generally awful at understanding and managing risk, and it is in no small part because there is almost anti-training about risk outside of high-risk activities, and even some of those are very low on guidance and high on PDL. >> I still wouldn't feel bad - that's the way they chose to live thier life. True, 'tho I feel like it is my better to not die soon-ish doing what I love, but enjoy many decades of doing what I love; doing it a little smarter and sometimes not quite at Warp-9 every second, so I can do more Warp-9 seconds later. I used to be an alpine ski racer, downhill my best event. At one national championship, the lower half of the race course was pretty flat and the race organizers decided to spice up one of the drop-offs with a bigger jump, building an illegal ramp before the drop-off (the FIS rules for Downhill stated that features cannot be sloped up before the racers leave the ground, level or down-slope only). I decided I had the knowledge I needed without pushing it on that feature in training so shed some speed every training run. For the several days of training runs before the race, every afternoon we were visiting friends in the hospital with fairly serious injuries from that feature (one back injury never raced again and never fully recovered). By race day, they'd decided to make it legal and shaved off the ramp. I have never felt that I missed out on anything by being aggressive on the top and skipping the Warp-9 attitude there...
- antipotoad 4y agoI do feel bad when it seems needless. Lost a good friend to an avalanche in an avalanche-prone area, in dangerous conditions (weak layer in the snow from earlier in the season, big wet dump on top, turns into a slab slide so easily). He could and should have known better. He’s at peace now, as are those of us left behind. I just miss my friend.
- wildhereplzhold 4y agoIt's not that simple, though. Even if we can't eliminate them, we can do a lot to minimize the risks involved in fun, dangerous activities. Look at people like Ayrton Senna. Died doing what he loved, but he didn't have to, and the changes that his death inspired made F1 racing much safer without sacrificing the hair-raising speed. He also probably would have lived if the sport's governing body had learned from a prior serious crash on the ultimately fatal corner. Personally, I still feel bad about deaths like that.
- giantg2 4y agoDidn't Senna also have some religious thing that led home to believe he might die that day, but still chose to race? If it the safety upgrades were so easily identifiable, then why didn't people demand them sooner? The solutions implemented where only discovered/developed because of the crash. We can go back in time and see how many people would have been saved by seatbelts and airbags. I would guess there are additional future safety stuff that future people could look back on us the same way. It's just reality and I don't feel bad about that.