4 ms·
I understand "corporate death penalty" as a dissolution of the corporation, likely with some cool down time for the execs found guilty when they cannot work as
by nine_k 4y ago
I understand "corporate death penalty" as a dissolution of the corporation, likely with some cool down time for the execs found guilty when they cannot work as execs.
No violence should be involved. Large layoffs resulting from that won't be pleasant one bit though.
- fragmede 4y ago[flagged]
- jazzyjackson 4y agoI would suppose whoever is being forced to terminate their employees is doing so under the threat of state violence (men with guns), but the employees being fired are not being threatened with any force, they're just losing their job.
- bastawhiz 4y agoIf I start a company with the express purpose of having it commit crimes, it will be shut down and everyone employed will be fired. That's not on the government, that's on me, the employer. So then where is the line that we draw that says how badly a company needs to behave or how many crimes it needs to commit to justify it being dissolved? We should not tolerate crime for the sake of the livelihoods of the henchmen. "The death star is bad, but think of how many people would be unemployed if we stopped them" is exactly the argument they want you to make.
- nisegami 4y agoViolence is the only language the state knows.
- dabraham1248 4y agoThe theory is that, _once it becomes policy and happens a couple of times_, employees will pay attention to what their company is doing, and get out if they think they're in danger. It aligns individual morality with self interest, and will crater a company that starts sliding towards dissolution. Thus actual enforcement becomes almost a non-issue. I'm not sure I buy that the janitorial staff is supposed to keep up on the dark patterns in the sign up page, but that's the theory.
- anonymouskimmer 4y agoTo be consistent you'd have to be opposed to venture capital shutting down and selling off companies as well. To be fully consistent you'd have to be opposed to firings and layoffs in general (except as the result of a commission of a crime by the person so fired). I'd be happy with a corporate death penalty that resulted in the stockholders being wiped out, the executives (and possibly board) being fired and barred from the industry, and executive control of the company being taken over by someone like John J. Ray III. This would allow either a restructuring of the company or gradually winding it down in such a way that the non-executive employees and bondholders aren't screwed over.
- soco 4y agoI'm pretty confident it wouldn't come to layoffs. If Meta faced such a risk they would simply follow the rule. Remember how many times they threatened to leave EU?
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> dissolution of the corporation Corporations are a legal fiction. What does dissolving the corporation mean? Revoking its charter? Then what happens to its assets? If you return them to shareholders, you’ve given a boon to its wealthiest, who can now re-organise it free of prior liabilities. If you liquidate them, you’ve delivered a junior fine, since with real fines the fine gets paid before creditors. If you take it, you’ve expropriated (also, fines with extra steps). In every case, what you want from a “corporate death penalty” is better effected with actual penalties. A market-cap sized fine is more specific and more actionable than a “corporate death penalty,” which is why I suspect the latter is in circulation.
- nevdka 4y agoA corporation is an organisation. It has internal processes, both documented/formal, and undocumented/informal - 'the way we do things here'. There are teams and departments, and relationships between them. There are contracts and commitments to and from other organisations. Handshake deals. Unspoken agreements. Expectations around whose turn it is to get promoted. Culture. History. Group identity. And sometimes these are bad and need to be dissolved.
- Rebelgecko 4y agoHow do you dissolve people's history and identity. Imprison them until they're reeducated?