3 ms·
" The release also sadly lacks the full spectrum of special features that were available on the 2001 release, including script drafts and an hour-long documenta
by dylan604 4y ago
" The release also sadly lacks the full spectrum of special features that were available on the 2001 release, including script drafts and an hour-long documentary. "
This is something that I noticed as a pattern for DVD releases in general. When DVDs were first arriving, titles were slower to be released. There's plenty of reasoning behind this. However, "they" also did not know what level of effort would be required to get people to buy into DVDs. So the first DVDs were in effect overly produced with so much extra content. The first DVD that I bought was Contact, and the entire second disc is nothing but BTS and making of type content. Skip to the time when Blu-ray/HD-DVD were being introduced, and you had <$5 DVDs in bins at WalMart with 2 or 3 movies on it that had nothing but the movies with essentially no effort whatsoever being applied.
"When I revisited the film on Amazon a year or two ago, I realized I was watching a remastered HD version, which featured a more contemporary color grade, generally referred to as “teal-and-orange.” The bluish look of the theatrical release, which was reproduced in previous video versions, gave way to an overly greenish look that was common on HD transfers of 80s pictures."
With DVD still being SD, a lot of the films had digital masters like a DigiBeta or D1 tape format which made for excellent DVD sources. This meant the DVDs looked like how people had seen them (only much cleaner compared to VHS). For HD discs, the studios had to go back to the film sources to rescan them at HD resolution. Since they were going back to the negatives, the sources would need to go back through a color session. Most film types can't leave things alone and must always tweak, but even if they didn't it's a completely new color session and usually not the same colorist. Maybe for A-list titles did they get anything other than factory floor treatment. They had entire back libraries of films to get transferred. You also had the decisions of keeping OAR, reframing for 16x9 full frame, or even pan&scan 4x3. It was a tremendous amount of work, and the longer it took meant fewer sales. Let's not forget that some of the people that originally worked on titles could very much be "no longer available" to work with on the projects.
- HideousKojima 4y agoA similarly awful change was made to the color grading for several streaming releases of The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly. It feels like whoever did the color had just watched Breaking Bad and decided to imitate the "make any scenes in Mexico have an orange color grading" style but for the entire movie: https://imgur.io/a/Ub5MO5R https://imgur.io/a/Ub5MO5R
- dylan604 4y agojust like everything else, styles/trends come and go in color correction. my least favorite was the flat/desaturated look. although, i still have my suspicions that came from someone uninformed/unfamiliar with color grading that the digital camera they shot on recorded the image flat in expectation someone would grade it later. (Recording flat helps preserves details in highlights/shadows.) i could then absolutely see some one else mimicking that as a style and the whole thing snowballed. your examples GBU are less offensive to me than the desat look. however, i still agree that it's strange to change the whole look/feel of the movie. color grading is as much art as science, so no two people will do the same thing. one film-to-HD project i was involved in used a colorist that would be considered a grey beard (only he was clean shaven). he "knows" film just from the decades of working with it. when he received the film for the HD transfer, he looked at what stock the film was, and then found reference film of the same stock. he then based the colors off of that reference. the director was taken aback by how in all of the years of this film being transferred by various people for various projects, this version was the closest to actual color he had wanted it to look. so just a fun story about how sometimes changes can be good vs keep it as it was. i guess as all things, intent matters
- rebuilder 4y agoRe: the flat look, I, too, suspect it comes from log footage, although I’m not sure it has to do with not knowing. It could also just be that if you do your dailies and editing without a LUT, as seemed to be common at one point, you get used to the way it looks and are less likely to go for a very contrasty look in grading.
- dylan604 4y agoI've met more than one person that has admitted that they did not know anything about flat/log and just thought that's what the footage was supposed to look like. Not the sharpest tacks in the box, but not all "artists" are technically savvy. They had no idea about color correction because that was primarily the realm of film production. Up to that point, video cameras always came shot as full range. There was a big learning curve for non-techy shooters.
- wlesieutre 4y agoI think the bonus content on DVD mostly comes down to tossing in anything they could think of as an effort to say "this is so much more amazing than VHS" But it turns out what consumers actually care about is the better video quality
- dylan604 4y agoBonus content in the early days was a scramble to get produced. Eventually, it became part of the negotiations with the actors to make themselves available for bonus content just like their promotional tours. Producers also started paying for BTS docs to be produced during production just to have the content available. The docs definitely changed over time as not everyone cares about some of the detail. Edge cases remained like the LotR box sets with the details kept in vs let's just see famous people "at work". Yes, the quality difference in video/audio from VHS to DVD was a no-brainer kind of upgrade decision path. It was visible on the existing TV equipment already owned. That's also why HD-DVD/Blu-ray sales were not as large of a spike in the adoption rate. To see the difference between HD and a really nice SD DVD, you needed the larger screens which not everyone had. Otherwise, there was no noticeable difference between HD-down-convert to SD on an SD screen to the SD DVD. I was in that industry for both format introductions/adoption cycles. Once people started getting the larger HD screens, they could see how poorly the SD->HD conversions looked compared to HD sources.
- ghaff 4y agoDVD + HD didn't hit the quality plateau for everyone but it did for a lot of people. I'll generally buy BluRay discs on the rare occasions I buy a movie. But I'm not getting replacing a perfectly good 60" plasma TV in favor of whatever the latest and greatest is.
- everybodyknows 4y agoWhat is "OAR"?
- dylan604 4y agoOriginal Aspect Ratio. Typically, that would be 2.35 instead of 1.78 for 16x9. OAR fans will accept letterboxing on their 16x9 displays. Lots of people don't, and so they make a 1.78 out of the 2.35. Luckily, as time has passed, I think the full frame 16x9 versions are going away, and more people are accepting of the OAR and its letterboxing