3 ms·
> I make a simple claim: if macOS takes action to remediate malware then it ought to tell the user. Simple question: Do you agree or disagree with that claim?
by saagarjha 4y ago
> I make a simple claim: if macOS takes action to remediate malware then it ought to tell the user. Simple question: Do you agree or disagree with that claim?
I am fully supportive of keeping users informed of how their systems work, and I always will be. Many parts of Apple, and the software industry in general, don't care for this very much, so this is unfortunately not as universal as I would like it to be. There's a lot of places in their OS that Apple chooses to not prioritize this effort, or does a poor job.
It's important to note that "tell the user" is not actually all that simple, just like being the person who tells you your medical results doesn't just read out your blood test. Throwing up a "we detected 10 threats" notification is not relevant to most users. When a doctor sits down with you they are obligated (I believe legally?) to make sure you understand what the results mean, how confident they are of the conclusions, your risk factors that might have influenced what they found, and what your next steps are. The same applies to malware detection and remediation, except with "medicine" swapped with "computers" for things people don't really understand.
I work in this space on another platform, and the problems we regularly run into include things like:
* We aren't 100% confident that we've detected malware
* Users sometimes actually find malware to have some helpful functionality (e.g. photo filter app that uploads all your photos, not just the ones you hand it)
* Malware authors target mechanisms that we can provide feedback to users
* Saying you didn't find any malware can lead users to think there is no malware
* Users don't really know to do with "oh we found malware and fixed it for you"
…
There aren't impossible problems to solve (at least, I hope they aren't…) but they definitely require some thought. I don't quite know how Apple does malware scanning; my understanding was that they do a lot of signature matches which should help with "we are confident this is malware", but considering some of the behaviors described in the article ("macOS detected malware and didn't do anything?!") I suspect some of these are less reliable. In any case, I get the feeling that Apple has not prioritized notifying the user of this because they don't want to spent the time on it for whatever reason. They don't really want to keep it secret, hence the API for third parties to perhaps solve the problem for them, but they aren't doing it themselves. Perhaps they really should; I think it's fine to be upset about this. The specific complaint I had was that the author seemed to imply that Apple purposefully underdocumented the API and made it hard to use for normal people, when that wasn't the purpose of it at all.