6 ms·
Whatever you think of @reddit's march towards decline...this was my favorite part of the blog post...and something I hope rings with other popular sites: Here’
by danso 15y ago
Whatever you think of @reddit's march towards decline...this was my favorite part of the blog post...and something I hope rings with other popular sites:
Here’s a list of things we don’t (and won’t) do for traffic:
We don't get traffic through ads.
We don’t participate in any traffic trading.
We don’t email our users (unless they choose to enter an
email and then forget their password).
We don’t harass users to sign up.
We don’t harass users to invite their friends.
We don’t pester you to download our app.
We don’t use slideshows and other pageview gimmicks.
We don't know anything about SEO.
We don't integrate with Facebook.
We don't even link to our Facebook or twitter accounts.
- ig1 15y agoIf you're one of the 3-5 sites a user goes to everyday, you have a completely different set of rules from everyone else
- sjs 15y agoReddit didn't appear out of the ether as one of those sites. They built a user base like everyone else.
- blangblang 15y agoReddit didn't appear out of the ether as one of those sites. They built a user base in a manner unlike everyone else. FTFY.
- sjs 15y agoPoor wording on my part. What I meant is that they too had to build a user base from nothing.
- rudiger 15y agoRegarding the "decline" of Reddit: any site that gets 2 billion monthly page views is going to be wholly different from its incipient form of several years ago. Surely the users of Reddit who pine for its past have many alternatives today.
- leoedin 15y agoSome aspects of HN are very similar to the way reddit was four years ago. The topics covered are slightly different, but at least half of the HN main page is normally not directly startup related, and the discussion threads are almost always interesting. Hopefully it'll stay that well. Childish and one line comments seem to stay away, which is absolutely fantastic.
- sidswift 15y ago> but at least half of the HN main page is normally not directly startup related I agree with you, as HN is supposed to bring topics of interest for hackers, and there are many things other than startup world that we may be interested in. But for startup related items, the submissions are almost entirely devoted to software, computing and related services. There are very few (no?) posts related to startups in science or hardware (and we are living in times where very exciting things are happening in these areas). In my opinion, a hacker community will benefit from having a wide range of interests (I haven't seen Michael Neilsen posting here for a while).
- __alexs 15y agoThe alternatives often seem to come in the form of communities splintering. e.g. /r/gaming, /r/gamingnews /r/games, /r/truegaming etc. The expansion and decline in quality (i.e. rage comic spam) is usually followed quite rapidly by new sub-reddits being created and communities forming with stricter areas of moderation.
- acgourley 15y agoStill that is a suboptimal divide, and leaves a discovery problem. Someone will solve it and replace reddit in at least some profound ways.
- ubernostrum 15y agoSomeone will solve it and replace reddit in at least some profound ways. Doubtful. These are deep-seated patterns that have been playing out in online communities for decades, and every "oh we'll just build a new thing that won't have that problem" attempt has... had the same problems. For examples, and some interesting thoughts on the issue, start here: http://www.shirky.com/writings/group_enemy.html http://www.shirky.com/writings/group_enemy.html
- bialecki 15y agoNot to take a thing away from Reddit, but there are a lot of bored people out there and they don't know that many great places on the internet. To compound that, mobile devices have created more time when you can be doing something else (i.e. between commercials, on the bus, etc.). It's not that there aren't a lot of great websites out there, it's just that most people I know only go to 2-5 regularly. Reddit is a great site, but I know a lot of people who go there 30 minutes after they just clicked through 100 links hoping there's something new (and then when they're bored posting about it - http://www.reddit.com/search?q=blue+links http://www.reddit.com/search?q=blue+links). I'm not sure why, but either people can only remember a few websites, other sites suck or they can't be found.
- spindritf 15y agoBecause Reddit is not like those other sites. I have 130 feeds in my RSS reader, 9 pages on my speed dial (including HN and other forums) and still visit Reddit every once in a while.
- kayhi 15y agoMy concern is that this stand may hurt profitability. I don't think any of us want harassing or pestering, but have come across companies that it is a pleasure to read their email or invite friends.
- bad_user 15y agoAs with any user-generated content website, it has a problem: amongst those many users Reddit has there are also lots of dicks that spoil the conversations for everybody. I don't think Reddit wants to go on the path of Youtube - useful for finding out links, but with useless and rude conversations that make you mad at waisting time reading them. I think Reddit got popular because in addition to links, users had meaningful things to say about those links, but the overall quality has been constantly dropping. Reddit should try to find ways to alleviate this phenomenon. Here's a case study from today. I submitted a link to both HN and /r/programming [1] [2] Most popular comment and criticism on HN: 1. User tumblr. 2. You're done. Most popular comment and criticism on /r/programming: Scumbag programmer: Titles post "Blogging for Hackers". Writes the whole thing in Ruby. Edit: Whoops - looks like those Ruby rockstars woke up. [1] http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3428369 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3428369 [2] http://www.reddit.com/r/programming/comments/o3v2u/blogging_for_hackers/ http://www.reddit.com/r/programming/comments/o3v2u/blogging_...
- dekz 15y agoUnfortunately proggit has become a cesspool, a complete juxtaposition of what reddit once was. I'm not familiar nor certain of a case where this has been turned around? Is it even advantageous for Reddit to attempt to remove the dregs from their site?
- bad_user 15y agoIt is my belief (and from personal observation) that the bad apples constitute a very loud minority. Punishing just a couple and clearly promoting your values makes a big difference.
- dekz 15y agoI find it much harder to swallow the comments on reddit, at least here on HN there is a guideline which encourages comments which add to the discussion; whereas on reddit, it's a shamble of memes and novelty accounts which depending on the account handle are allowed to be rude/obnoxious/racist. I find it easier to leave proggit/reddit behind and follow Hacker News simply due to my alignment with the guidelines and the current HN hive-mind (no memes, helpful discussions).
- 127 15y agoThey do show stupid pictures ("Instead of an ad, here's...") instead of ads that steal my attention for no reason what so ever. The sole reason I'm using adblock. I do not want to, but those damn pictures are so damn annoying that I have no choice. How about not show anything if you are not going to show an ad? Why steal my attention and bother me for no reason at all?
- amitparikh 15y agoBecause reddit sometimes does show real ads in that space. And I think this feature was designed with 'fun' in mind -- it's lighthearted! References: http://blog.reddit.com/2010/10/fun-in-sidebar.html http://blog.reddit.com/2010/10/fun-in-sidebar.html and http://www.reddit.com/r/blog/comments/dqse4/fun_in_the_sidebar/ http://www.reddit.com/r/blog/comments/dqse4/fun_in_the_sideb...
- 127 15y agoWhat you consider "fun" and "lighthearted" I consider a waste of space and attention. Tell me how it is logically not.
- redthrowaway 15y agoClearly you aren't their target market. The "instead of an ad, here's x" pictures have proven to be fairly popular.
- whatusername 15y agoBecause having something "fun" and "lighthearted" in the space occasionally might drive higher cpm's when they actually sell ads for the space.
- vecter 15y agoTheir revenue comes from ads. They've never claimed otherwise, what makes you think they did?
- 15y ago
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- roel_v 15y agoHere's one they forgot: We don't make enough money to sustain ourselves.