5 ms·
> but that the cost-benefit ratio for highways is actually rather low, because highway lanes are so low capacity and fill up fast. (A standard metro line can ea
by rayiner 4y ago
> but that the cost-benefit ratio for highways is actually rather low, because highway lanes are so low capacity and fill up fast. (A standard metro line can easily carry 30-60k persons per direction per hour; the figure for a highway lane is 2.5k.)
That’s not the complete cost benefit calculation. A 4-lane highway costs $5-10 million per mile in suburban areas. Meanwhile, the DC Metro’s recent expansion through exurban Virginia mostly along an existing right of way cost $200 million per mile: https://www.heritage.org/transportation/commentary/washingtons-new-6-billion-metro-line-needs-simpler-solutions https://www.heritage.org/transportation/commentary/washingto.... So even if the rail carries three times as many people, it costs 20 to 40 times as much money per mile.
That’s the cost side. On the benefit side, few places can saturate a subway line that carries 30,000 passengers per hour. Over the Thanksgiving weekend, just 5,000 people per day used the new Silver Line stops in Virginia. Even the design estimate of the Silver Line was 30,000 per day, and actual use has been a fraction of that. So the benefit side of the equation is a lot lower than the theoretical peak.
- bobthepanda 4y agoIt makes more sense to compare like for like. The current project to expand I-66 in the DC suburbs of Virginia is $3.7B, which is $160M per mile along an existing right of way.
- rblatz 4y agoHow many lanes are being added as part of this expansion?
- bobthepanda 4y agoTwo lanes in each direction. https://www.fhwa.dot.gov/ipd/project_profiles/va_transform_66.aspx https://www.fhwa.dot.gov/ipd/project_profiles/va_transform_6...
- danny_codes 4y agoSo about 10x more expensive per person hmm
- rayiner 4y agoOnly $2.3 billion is for construction of the express lanes, so $100 million per mile. And it’s not like with like. The Silver line was constructed on an existing median that had been reserved for it decades ago. The I-66 express lane expansion required buying more land alongside the existing right of way. The 4 new express lanes will also carry 5,000 vehicles per hour in each direction, which is as much as the total ridership of the Silver Line (outside the Beltway) in an entire day. Also, the actual cost to the state will be much lower. People highly value point to point driving access. So the express lanes can charge tolls up to $40.
- bobthepanda 4y ago> On the benefit side, few places can saturate a subway line that carries 30,000 passengers per hour. It should be noted, that this is actually pretty good; this is an investment that will last decades, because it will take that long to fill it up, whereas a highway investment will easily need to be repeated over, and over, and over again. (There's a joke that in some states there are two seasons: winter and road construction.)
- rayiner 4y agoNo, filling up is a good thing. Both the rail and the highway will last for decades. But the highway will be delivering its maximum benefit immediately. (When the highway is expanded, it will be delivering new benefit to additional commuters.) While with the rail, you have paid a bunch of money up front for capacity that’s unused for years if not decades. (Parts of the suburban Metro network on the Maryland side are 40+ years old and nowhere near capacity.) It’s like building a skyscraper. It’s not a good thing if it’s only 25% leased for years and years.
- TheCoelacanth 4y agoThe under utilization mostly comes down to poor urban planning by the jurisdictions that it runs through. They should be allowing construction of unlimited density within a quarter-mile of stations. Instead, many of the stations are surrounded by basically nothing.
- danny_codes 4y agoAt the end of the day, metro is always going to be cheaper overall than cars as a mode of travel. Think about it. Let's take the bay area as an example. We have 7 million people or so. I would wager cars per capita is like 0.8 or something but let's round down to 5 million cars in the bay. Car ownership is about 9k per year. So that's about 45 billion a year in car ownership costs alone. Now, let's say we built a good metro/ public transit in the bay, such that a family doesn't need a car, but some will still have them. So maybe there are still a million cars, saving us about 35 billion a year. Operating costs for NYC metro are about 400 million a year. Let's say the bay is 20x more expensive and spends 8 billion a year on operating costs for a truly world-class transit system. That means every year we'd save about 20 billion by using transit. So even if the capitol cost of building out a good transit system in the bay is 300 billion, we'd be saving money in just 15 years. And of course this completely discounts the astonishing negative externalities of cars w.r.t land use and economic value. The math is just not going to work out in favor of cars. The development model is trash. And of course it's trash when you think about how it scales. Every person needs a car! Every person needs an extremely complex, expensive machine that consumes vastly more energy than the alternative! A subway car presumably services thousands of people a day. The average car services one person. Car manufacturers have been exceedingly successful at gaslighting Americans for the better part of a century. A little critical thinking can help
- xyzzyz 4y agoYour figures are completely, utterly off, in so many ways. > Operating costs for NYC metro are about 400 million a year. I don’t know where you got this figure from, but this is off by a factor 20x. $400M won’t even cover NYC MTA’s electricity bill. The actual operating cost is closer to $8B. Does being completely off with your calculations affect your thinking about transportation economics? I seriously doubt that.
- JamesBarney 4y agoIn addition 45% of households in NYC own a car.
- TheCoelacanth 4y agoYou can't stop the analysis with current usage. One of the primary motivations for building the Silver Line was to allow denser construction in the areas around the new stations. It will take years or decades for all of the new construction unlocked by the Silver Line to finish.