4 ms·
> The original OGL granted “perpetual, worldwide, non-exclusive license” to the Open Game Content (commonly called the System Resource Document) and directed th
by londons_explore 4y ago
> The original OGL granted “perpetual, worldwide, non-exclusive license” to the Open Game Content (commonly called the System Resource Document) and directed that licensees “may use any authorized version of this License to copy, modify and distribute any Open Game Content originally distributed under any version of this License.” But the updated OGL says that “this agreement is…an update to the previously available OGL 1.0(a), which is no longer an authorized license agreement.”
I wasn't under the impression that such an authorization could be revoked... Specifically, if someone is living in a cave with OGL v1.0(a), and churning out works according to its terms, then it isn't their responsibility to check every day if the copy they are using has suddenly become not-authorized.
Nor can Hasbro send them an official notification that they have withdrawn authorization, because they have no way to find said person. And any reseller need not reveal the identity of the cave dweller creator who is still using OGL 1.0.
- voidfunc 4y agoPerpetual doesn't imply anything about revocability (thats irrevocable). The law doesn't operate in this stupid vacuum like software engineers believe it does.
- londons_explore 4y agoBut from a logistical point of view, is it possible to revoke a license from a person that you don't know the name and address of, and have no way to find it? I think you'd be hard pressed to tell a court that you want to sue an unnamed person for following the terms of a license that you granted to them, then revoked but haven't told them you revoked, and that you don't know their name or address...
- patmcc 4y agoThe law doesn't care all that much about logistics, for one. More importantly a license like this only practically matters for published work, and published work is generally not completely anonymous; WOTC doesn't know everyone who has published something under the OGL but they certainly know of Paizo, Roll20, Critical Role, etc. and fundamentally those are the ones they care about. If Jim your local DM keeps writing homebrew they won't know, but it's also not who they're aiming at (yet).
- ajross 4y agoThat's true, but it also adheres closely to ideas like "common sense". It's hard to imagine how to interpret the use of "perpetual" in the original OGL that doesn't imply "irrevocable"; certainly nothing else in a blanket license like this is going to be time-limited. I dunno, but I'd want to see someone cite some case law where a "perpetual" license was allowed to be revoked like this. It certainly smells off to me. Obviously WotC isn't obligated to license any new content under an older OGL, it can use whatever terms it wants. But as for existing OGL content, I think they're on some very "innovative" ground here, legally.
- tptacek 4y agoFrom the reading I've done, I don't think there's much controversy about this: perpetual licenses aren't automatically irrevocable; they're separate concepts. A perpetual license is just a license without an expiration date. There are other reason I've read that 1.0 could be effectively irrevocable, but the word "perpetual" isn't, I don't think, one of them? https://assets.fenwick.com/legacy/FenwickDocuments/Technology_Licensing.pdf https://assets.fenwick.com/legacy/FenwickDocuments/Technolog... "Perpetual means a string of infinite length; irrevocable means a string, of any length, that cannot be cut."
- ajross 4y agoThat still seems like an extremely narrow reading of a license that has been in regular use in an industry selling real products for 20 years. Literally everyone, including WotC, has gone on behaving as if this was "irrevocable". And only now it's not, because of a technical reading of the text of the license? That's not really the spirit of this kind of thing, and courts aren't computers. FWIW: I'll also note that the GPLv2 doesn't contain the word "irrevocable". Do we really believe that software authors of critical societal infrastructure should be empowered to do this kind of rug pull?
- tptacek 4y agoKaren Sandler and Heather Meeker on why GPL2 is irrevocable: https://www.zdnet.com/article/no-you-cant-take-open-source-code-back/ https://www.zdnet.com/article/no-you-cant-take-open-source-c...
- LorenPechtel 4y agoThat's my impression, also. It seems to me Hasbro can refuse to license anything new under the 1.0 agreement but what's out there is out there and they can't change that. They'll just force their competition not to use the new material.