3 ms·
> There is no evidence of tampering. There is evidence of a supply chain vulnerability. The voting machine software's Makefile downloads unaudited libraries st
by matheusmoreira 4y ago
> There is no evidence of tampering.
There is evidence of a supply chain vulnerability. The voting machine software's Makefile downloads unaudited libraries straight off the internet and links them to the final binary prior to signing. This is literally written in the armed forces audit report. Surely you agree that it's game over should there be malicious code in those libraries. Surely you agree that nation states are perfectly capable of executing these attacks, including Biden's CIA goons who pressured Bolsonaro not to question the machines.
Election authorities are the ones who need to demonstrate beyond doubt that this system is not vulnerable. They could have done that by releasing source code and the signed binaries that ran on the machines on the day of the election. Instead, they doubled down on their mistake, declared the machines "unquestionable" and started oppressing anyone who protested the results. As far as I'm concerned that is evidence enough.
"No evidence of tampering" is what these journalists claim. Apparently they searched the report for affirmations of fraud, found none and declared the whole thing fraudulent. They couldn't care less about the vulnerability described above. "You can't hack an offline calculator", they tell me. I don't expect laymen to understand but I sure as hell didn't think I'd see hacker news users defending this.
- vaidhy 4y ago>Election authorities are the ones who need to demonstrate beyond doubt that this system is not vulnerable. There is nothing where something can be beyond doubt. It can be beyond reasonable doubt.. but you can always bring up one more "doubt" one level up. At what point would you say we should be trust something?
- matheusmoreira 4y agoYou're right, "beyond doubt" is probably an impossibly high standard. Still, they have not proven anything beyond reasonable doubt either. A supply chain vulnerability is pretty much the definition of reasonable doubt. Answering such doubt with oppression and censorship is enough for the entire system to be illegitimate to me. Any talk of "anti-democratic acts" is quite simply hilarious coming from these tyrants. > At what point would you say we should be trust something? I'll trust the results if TSE releases everything publicly, including source code and binaries, and the worldwide community of hackers and cryptographers finds no problems with it. Their current "auditing" process where you're allowed restricted access to the code with nothing on your person other than pen and paper is complete bullshit and I do not believe it.
- rbanffy 4y ago> and I do not believe it. The parties seem satisfied with the level of access they have and no law mandating a different process was ever voted. I suggest that instead of invading buildings the people who don't believe in election results start believing in the Rule of Law and understand that the process to change legislation doesn't include threats of violence.
- matheusmoreira 4y ago> no law mandating a different process was ever voted No. During Bolsonaro's mandate, there was an attempt to add an auditable paper trail to the voting machines. It was voted unconstitutional by the same judges who would go on to declare the election results "unquestionable". I don't blame them for using violence. Censorship is unconstitutional, especially political censorship, yet that's exactly what the judges who interpret the constitution did. How can you speak of "rule of law"? Clearly, "rule of law" is a joke here.
- rbanffy 4y ago> During Bolsonaro's mandate, there was an attempt to add an auditable paper trail to the voting machines. The proposal (to vote on the machine and deposit a printout in a bag) would risk the secrecy of the vote. It was, therefore, considered unconstitutional. And rightfully so. There was a vote printer that could be attached to the 2002 machine. I worked on it. It was unreliable and the different operations flow was confusing. It was deemed impractical (because a mechanical failure could cause the whole ballot to be discarded, and mechanical failures aren't that difficult to provoke). And nothing justifies the violence. They should accept the election results like responsible adults do and, if not, use the legal path to question it.
- commoner 4y agoHN users in general are not going to support a militant attack motivated by concerns that are not backed by hard evidence. Free and open source software is the gold standard, but the fact that election machines used proprietary software is not nearly enough to justify the attack.
- matheusmoreira 4y ago[flagged]
- commoner 4y agoI don't know of any country that uses only free and open source software for its election machines. By your standards, any militant attack after any election woth election machines would be justified, because proprietary software was involved. I reject that reasoning, since it is nonpragmatic to the point of extremism. Of course it would be ideal to incorporate FOSS into the election process, but this militant attack is both unnecessary to achieve this and unjustifiable based on the weakness of the arguments against election integrity. Also, this attack appears to be aimed at overriding the result of the election, not at increasing FOSS uptake in future elections.
- matheusmoreira 4y agoYou are ignoring the supply chain vulnerability discovered in the voting software build process. Source code and binaries release are the only things that could legitimitize this election at this point. I want to reverse engineer the binary and see if I can find any malicious code in those unaudited libraries. I simply won't have any confindence in the results unless I do that myself. This is not extremism either. Why should anyone recognize representatives produced by a faulty process? That's bullshit. This is not extremism at all. I don't care about "pragmatism" either, they have to do it right or not do it at all. They have two legitimate choices: produce a resilient and transparent election system or relinquish their power. They took a third option by forcing this questionable system down our throats and doubling down on their mistake when problems inevitably surfaced; what you're seeing right now is the result.