4 ms·
It can be a crime in some states depending on the circumstances, especially if audio is captured.
by giantg2 4y ago
It can be a crime in some states depending on the circumstances, especially if audio is captured.
- toomuchtodo 4y agoDifferent shades from a release for being in the shot versus recording someone’s conversation, but an important call out nonetheless. Interestingly, I haven’t heard of any criminal cases where social media folks have recorded and shared public conversations on platforms (TikTok, r/PublicFreakout, etc). Doesn’t mean they don’t exist, so if you’ve got case law to share, drop it here. I presume (Not a lawyer! Not legal advice!) that depending on jurisdiction, you may record anything in public assuming there is no expectation of privacy in the situation. https://www.aapsonline.org/judicial/telephone.htm https://www.aapsonline.org/judicial/telephone.htm https://www.theverge.com/2018/10/24/18015374/whyd-you-push-that-button-record-stranger-public https://www.theverge.com/2018/10/24/18015374/whyd-you-push-t...
- giantg2 4y agoIn general, that's true. However there are exceptions. Things like upskirt shots, recording in courtrooms, recording full or partial nudity (ie filming sunbathers), etc.
- kencausey 4y agoIn other words, intent matters.
- hervature 4y agoI don't think GP said anything about intent. If you "accidentally" upskirt someone and release it on TikTok, the victim and the court isn't going to be too impressed with "I didn't mean to and didn't notice it before uploading". Of course, there is some expectation of "within reason". Like, if you have to look at the reflection in the window, it is entirely reasonable to think someone may not have noticed before uploading.
- Wistar 4y agoA Maryland case where a motorcyclist, using a helmet cam, video & audio records a cop brandishing a gun. Motorcyclist posts the video online only to be arrested and charged with a felony for having made the recording. The court threw out the charges. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maryland_v._Graber https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maryland_v._Graber
- dclowd9901 4y agoWhat can be a crime? If you’re in a public space (and not the legal definition of public —- a mall is considered a public space despite being privately owned) you have no legal expectation of privacy. Period. End of story. There are very good reasons for this, despite the fact in creative tiktokers are definitely exercising the bounds of the law. Of course if the content somehow slanders or misrepresents someone, that’s another issue.
- pronlover723 4y agoI tend to agree with your POV but as a counterpoint, in Japan it's against the law to film people in public without their permission. A shot of a crowd is unlikely to get you in trouble, and in fact, a shot taken without permission but that the person you took it of never finds out is unlikely to get you in trouble (although that's the same for shoplifting) But, it is the law there and it is often enforced. As an example you can find public exhibitions with signs up "no photography". You'll even find these signs at trade shows at many booths where you'd expect the entire point is to show off to the public. The point is, different cultures have different feelings about this. IIUC, it was Japan that made Google Maps remove faces from streetview.
- dahart 4y agoNot sure why this is getting downvoted, I believe it’s correct for the U.S. Reminds me of the famous “Photographer’s Rights” pamphlet http://www.krages.com/ThePhotographersRight.pdf http://www.krages.com/ThePhotographersRight.pdf and there definitely are people out there making confrontation videos with security guards and police for YouTube based on knowing they can’t legally be stopped for shooting in public. It might be lame, but it is legal.
- darekkay 4y ago> Not sure why this is getting downvoted, I believe it’s correct for the U.S. That's the problem: A US-centric "end of story, period" generalization. In general, you are not allowed to take pictures of other people in public without their consent in Germany and many other countries.