5 ms·
I find it ironic (and a bit annoying) that the logic used in the article's title is the same logic that led to the high unemployment rate for architects: If a p
by gk1 15y ago
I find it ironic (and a bit annoying) that the logic used in the article's title is the same logic that led to the high unemployment rate for architects: If a profession is in high demand today, it will still be in high demand four years from now. And conversely, if a profession is in low demand now, then it will remain so for the next four years (hence the title of the article).
- hkmurakami 15y agoI've recently had the same worry for the current explosion in need for web front end engineers and designers. In the next 5 years, perhaps we will see a great increase in the number of such skilled individuals coming out of colleges across the country. But what's going to happen to them if the current high times of the web industry suddenly takes a turn for the worse? The situation may be similar to what "architecture majors" are facing right now.
- Jtsummers 15y agoThis happened with programming/IT a few years ago. Many people entered into college in 1998-2002 with the impression that they would practically have to fight off the job offers. Of course, it didn't quite turn out that way. However, the impression remained and students continued enrolling in CS programs because there was money in programming. A consequence of this was an excess of employees and a relative dearth of jobs (or again that was the impression) so they flooded grad schools instead. Many schools saw record enrollment levels in the 2005-2008 time frame. This cycle is not new, nor will it cease to occur. People generally follow the trends which means they are typically late to the party. EDIT: To add another situation. The early 2000s were a great time for the housing market so many builders began ramping up construction projects with the anticipation of sales and no actual sales. The consequence of this is decent housing developments with <150k$ homes that would easily have pushed 200k$ a few years earlier, assuming the builders didn't abandon the projects altogether. Now no one wants to buy (or can't if they've become unemployed or been hit with paycuts/furloughs) and these cheap homes remain on the market.
- dabent 15y agoI was through the rough market in 2002, when it was rumored that all software would be written in India by 2012. If I recall, enrollment in CS, engineering math and the sciences dropped dramatically. The thing is, I don't think enrollment has gone back up, in spite of it now seeming "cool" to be involved in a software startup again. I've seen articles on HN and elsewhere on how hard it is to get people involved in CS or other math and science related majors recently. I guess that's a good thing for me, the middle-aged programmer, as it means less competition for my job, but I'm not sure it's good for any country (I'm in the US) in the long term.
- dangrossman 15y agoYes, CS enrollment dropped and kept dropping until 2007. Since then it's been growing, but very slowly; 2010 CS degree program enrollment was only 14% higher than it was in 2007. Grad program enrollment was up something like 2% over 2009.
- simonbrown 15y agoOr the dotcom bubble?
- brudgers 15y agoIt will not be similar because unlike architecture (in the US), there are no legal barriers to web development. In the US, architects are licensed state by state. All states require at least three years of structured experience and a series of tests to demonstrate minimum competency for licensure - one cannot practice without a license. Most states require an accredited professional degree of at least five years (Bachelor of Architecture) those which do not typically require additional experience beyond three years depending on degree type.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- eternalban 15y agoIf your are implying that an rise/spike in enrollment in architecture programs was because the students were counting on having a job (because of a building boom of some kind) after the end of the program, I beg to differ. (MArch here.) Architecture is one of those passion fields that you enter knowing full well that the barrier to entry to becoming established is very high. It is also not a meritocratic field (like software). Everyone in my school (Columbia/GSAP) knew that at the end of the program, we were looking at n years of slavery for some big name architect (if lucky) and it was all together hugely competitive. After all, we had the example of our instructors (some of them highly regarded talents) who were mostly "paper architects" and pamphleteers. Many of us elected not to go that route and branched out to computer graphics, modeling, and some like me ended up being software engineers, instead of spending the next few years drawing bathroom details for some commodity architectural firm, hoping for future glory. (Yes, ego is a big driver for architects, and possibly a job requirement.) So regarding the current unemployed numbers, I would be curious to know what percentage are electing to remain unemployed due to perfectly reasonable reluctance to do banal work after having spent anywhere from 4 to 7 years pursuing their passion for excellence in design.