3 ms·
I don't think I'm doing a "no true Scotsman" thing, I don't think it's purism to try to use the meaning of words that held for a century to point out that the a
by cmrdporcupine 4y ago
I don't think I'm doing a "no true Scotsman" thing, I don't think it's purism to try to use the meaning of words that held for a century to point out that the accusations about "left wing bias" in media, etc. are absurd.
But I think we actually agree more than disagree: all the cultural stuff has taken the place of actual left wing politics.
Because socialist politics in the west was defeated, politically, in the 80s and 90s.
The "right wing" won. There's no real anti-capitalism left. People who might consider themselves left wing are really just playing with cultural shibboleths, acting out a part, because stating actual left wing opinions (e.g. "we should nationalize the oil industry") is so far out of the political mainstream that you can become absolutely ex-communicated for speaking these opinions in public. They're so dead, that you look like a crazy lunatic.
And the corruption you're speaking about in the union movement, etc. is IMHO a product of that. They become ossified into guilds and mafia-like clubs (this has always been a pressure). Because actually within the union movement historically it was rank and file socialists & communists who were pushing the unions away from that kind of thing historically, and the lack of a principled radical movement in the unions leads directly to corruption. (Look up the Teamsters for a Democratic Union sometime, for an example)
Socialism does not exist as a political force in the United States, unless you ridiculously redefine socialism to mean "anything government does."
Is there a liberal media vs conservative media war in the US? Yes. I just think it's absurd to frame this around "left" vs "right". It again takes us back to these stupid football teams.