2 ms·
I disagree it’s a very limited setting. We are constantly moving to less constrained problems. What used to be a very limited setting is now perhaps a somewha
by Retric 4y ago
I disagree it’s a very limited setting.
We are constantly moving to less constrained problems. What used to be a very limited setting is now perhaps a somewhat limited one. The options aren’t binary chose of using A* for pathing in a video game or AGI, it’s finding ever more generalizable solutions to ever wider range of problems.
The thing is as processing power keeps improving we need ever fewer limits to active human levels of performance from these systems. I don’t think AGI is just waiting for sufficient flops, but I think that’s closer to the truth than we want to admit.
- usrbinbash 4y ago> I disagree it’s a very limited setting. An automated vehicle has a couple of well defined controls. It cannot play the piano. It cannot recommend products. It cannot take a picture and tell me what kind of bird that is. In fact, it probably cannot even drive offroad, despite that being a very closely related task to what it is made to do. A person trained to drive a car on roads may have difficulty time on his first few offroad drives, but can quickly aquire the skills. He won't be completely unable to function either, because to a human, navigating is navigating, whether we walk through our own homes, or drive a vehicle over rough terrain. To AI as we currently understand it, all of these are completely different tasks.
- Retric 4y agoDriving a car involves effectively infinite possible choices over time. It’s both qualitatively and quantitatively vastly less constrained than chess. Classifying them both as very limited is clearly wrong. Also, the DARPA grand challenge was for self driving cars off road, it’s a simpler problem no need to check for traffic lights and stop signs it’s the same general problem. Which brings up another possibility, there are only so many tasks we might want AI for so specific systems for every single one is effectively the same thing as AGI.