3 ms·
> You're not considering how influence is measured objectively. > The leading philosophy schools today are in those countries, as evidenced by published output
by thaumasiotes 4y ago
> You're not considering how influence is measured objectively.
> The leading philosophy schools today are in those countries, as evidenced by published output and citations.
Making an objective measurement of the wrong thing doesn't give you grounds to make a claim. I could make a list of "The 50 Most Influential Living Philosophers" as defined by how long they can hold a note before needing to breathe, and it would be objective, but so what? Those wouldn't actually be a set of 50 influential philosophers.
A list of "50 most influential living philosophers" that doesn't include Jorge Bergoglio is a list that's telling you no effort was made to connect the title of the list to the contents. Regardless of what you think of his abilities in philosophy, it's his job and he's beating everyone on that list for influence.
- PaulRobinson 4y agoFirstly, don't take listicles too seriously. But more importantly, how is the ability to hold a note before needing to breathe a useful and objective measure how "most influential" a philosopher is?
- thaumasiotes 4y agoIt's like you didn't even read my comment. The ability to hold a note is just as useful a measure of how influential a philosopher is as citations in academic journals is. That's what I just said, right above you.
- PaulRobinson 4y agoSo you think published output and reference to that output is not as equally a valid objective measure of influence in an academic setting as singing well? OK, we're so far apart on this I'll just wish you godspeed on your rather perverse intellectual journey!
- hnfong 4y agoIt proves that the alleged philosopher is quite alive. Not sure how academic citations proves that (quite the contrary).
- hackandthink 4y agoDid not know: Jorge Bergoglio is the pope und seems to be an intellectual. Never heard of Catholic dialecticism.