3 ms·
I started to use the term "fracking" for this[0], because that's more-less what the likes of Uber, AirBnB, Doordash, etc. do to their respective markets: they p
by TeMPOraL 4y ago
I started to use the term "fracking" for this[0], because that's more-less what the likes of Uber, AirBnB, Doordash, etc. do to their respective markets: they pump billions of VC money like it was a fracking fluid, in order to crack the market, pump out all the value, and leave behind a toxic mess for the locals to deal with.
While I agree that startups can disrupt the big monopolies, past Uber, I now find them just as dangerous as big companies to the customers and the societies they live in. Perhaps more so, because big companies don't have to disrupt anything to extract their rents.
I feel startups are not like they used to be. Or maybe they always were what they were, and I became disillusioned only recently. Either way, today, this is a well-developed process of wealth transfer. In a sense, startups aren't something opposite to big companies - they're the means big companies use to frack an existing market and pump out all value. Startups are an integral part of the market ecosystem now, and from the POV of those at the top, it's arguably a symbiotic, not parasitic relationship.
--
[0] - I used to call it "strip-mining a market for all its worth", pointing at fast extraction of value with no concerns about sustainability, but I think "fracking" is better, as it also evokes the image of first cracking the market by a sudden, focused infusion of seemingly infinite free money.
- b1zguy 4y agoI did the term 'fracking' in this context. I'll start using it.
- cudgy 4y agoOne could also call it a “cash bonfire”
- TeMPOraL 4y agoI'd wish. If all that happened was some people setting billions on fire, it wouldn't be that bad. The fracking analogy highlights that 1) those billions are used to eviscerate markets and industries, 2) it's a dirty process leaving a lot of collateral damage, and 3) the parties doing it are actually making a profit, so this process is self-sustaining (as long as there still are markets to frack).
- cudgy 4y agoAgreed. There are definitely adverse effects to the markets from these practices. Could it be that the conglomeration of the startups controlled or at least heavily influenced by a few dominant VC firms essentially creates an oligopoly in the tech startup world? In other words, these startups, which behave like monopolies by razing certain markets with low prices while losing money, are small tentacles of the huge vc firms that are funded by large stockholders of the FAANG oligopolies.
- pessimizer 4y agoIt's just dumping to me, like heavily subsidized US corn exports into Mexico after NAFTA.
- thefaux 4y ago> I feel startups are not like they used to be. I've had a similar epiphany over the last five years or so. Once you take money from the VCs, you are essentially just an R&D department of the VC collective with perhaps a bit more autonomy than you might have in a BigCo but you are still heavily constrained by the demands of your funders. This is nothing like the romantic two guys in a garage with a great idea taking on the world narrative that we've been fed for decades.
- spacemadness 4y agoI love the turn of perception here that’s being acknowledged out loud finally. I have a feeling HN would have buried this sentiment around 8 years ago a lot of folks here were busy fracking as hard as they could. Our capitalist system in America in general feels exceptionally worn out with guards placed at the gates to any real innovative work.