3 ms·
This headline format really needs to die. There's no story here beyond 'California's reservoirs are not sufficiently large to offset all water losses from drou
by anigbrowl 4y ago
This headline format really needs to die.
There's no story here beyond 'California's reservoirs are not sufficiently large to offset all water losses from drought, or to capture all rainfall during flood weather.' It's great clickbait because the same story is likely to be true under almost any conceivable range of circumstances.
- labrador 4y agoThis story is a perennial favorite that is trotted out every time it rains heavily enough to cause flooding. I also agree the headline format sucks because it's lazy clickbait format.
- googlryas 4y agoThat's way too long of a headline. And if it was just "California's reservoirs are not sufficiently large", or something, doesn't that imply that they should be increased in volume?
- Waterluvian 4y agoTake a positive spin: “California’s reservoirs full early in rain conveyor whatever it’s called now” Ie. tell them they met their goals early!
- AuthorizedCust 4y agoThey are far from full: https://cdec.water.ca.gov/resapp/RescondMain https://cdec.water.ca.gov/resapp/RescondMain
- kec 4y agoHow? Reservoirs take up enormous amounts of land, are ecologically disruptive and increase flood risk, especially if the embankments are allowed to dry out during times of drought.
- sliken 4y agoAfter a week of storms the reservoirs had moved from 33% full to 34% full. It's not that they aren't large enough, it's just the watersheds that lead into them aren't particularly large relative to the state. I lived near Berryessa and yes it raid from a low of 394 on Dec 20th to 399 today. It's still 40 feet under the spillway, which I've seen activated before.
- fdr 4y agoThe existing reservoirs are, generally, nowhere close to full. https://www.sfchronicle.com/weather/article/Here-s-where-California-reservoirs-stand-after-17700534.php https://www.sfchronicle.com/weather/article/Here-s-where-Cal... Looking at the contents of the interview, the problem looks more to be in aquifer recharge. Also probably runoff, and nitrogen pollution (especially, but among others) I bet.
- human_person 4y agoBut is it about the average state of the reservoir or the extreme case of catching (all) the water you get during unlikely but intense weather events?
- fdr 4y agoI’m not sure what you mean. The reservoirs tend to sit at a watershed’s egress point, runoff is obligated to pass through it. If there’s ample room in the reservoir, no runoff is lost. I think a correct reading of the article, which is perhaps too oblique on this point, is the loss of water to runoff where it is not in a watershed with a major reservoir, and not able to infiltrate into the aquifer. Add some runoff, such as agricultural runoff, is heavily polluted, complicating the matter even more.
- gerdesj 4y agoGet a grip. I'm a Brit so 7000 zillion miles away from CA. The title says x is an issue and the article tries to answer it. I'm reading stuff about somewhere else and why not? CA is famously in a long term drought and yet it is being short term very heavily rained on. I cannot fault the article title - it is a very obvious question. This seems pertinent: "Some of it can be captured for later, but the short answer is it falls so quickly that we lack the ability to take that water and set it aside quickly enough in a place where we can store it for later. The primary forms of storage for water in California are the snowpack, that typically accumulates annually, and then reservoirs behind dams, and then groundwater aquifers."
- dang 4y agoCan you please omit swipes like "Get a grip" from your HN posts? This is in the site guidelines: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html, and your otherwise fine comment would be much better without that bit. (I realize things like that aren't cardinal sins or anything but they poison the ecosystem in a way that doesn't automatically self-correct the way it can in smaller groups or more private forums. On HN it makes a big difference when commenters throw these things in vs. restrain themselves from doing so.)
- gerdesj 4y agoMessage received.
- bee_rider 4y agoIt feels like the journalist is channeling the guy from the xkcd. https://xkcd.com/793/ https://xkcd.com/793/
- adolph 4y agoHe’s not wrong tho. A nuclear explosion would blow the water back into the atmosphere as vapor where it will cool with fallout and join the snowpack. Just add potassium iodide to the municipal water supplies. Putting “challenge” in the headline is pure clickbait.
- random314 4y agoI read the short article and your summary. Your summary is terrible and misses several details 1. The reservoirs are already full 2. Not all the water can be channeled as ground water because of water quality and throughput issues 3. The primary sources depend on slow melting of the snowpack. But the water is coming in too fast to form a snow pack and gets washed away
- baggy_trough 4y agoThey are not close to full.
- AuthorizedCust 4y agoFar from full: https://cdec.water.ca.gov/resapp/RescondMain https://cdec.water.ca.gov/resapp/RescondMain
- ec109685 4y agoThere are full reservoirs: “ And the challenge is that when we get a lot of rainfall like this, it's not forming snowpack in lower areas. And reservoirs tend to fill up rather quickly. Then we have aquifers, and they have space, but it's hard to get water where it needs to be so it can infiltrate into the ground. And even then, it's hard to get it in fast enough.”
- sieabahlpark 4y ago[dead]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- dang 4y agoOk, I've attempted a neutral title using language from the article that will satisfy your and the different commenters' criticisms here. If anyone suggests a better title (i.e. more accurate and neutral, preferably using representative language from the article), we can change it again.
- anigbrowl 4y agoReally, I don't mind it being posted on HN (even though I think the article is clickbaity). If anything, changing the title obsures the issue because readers won't see it as the clickbait it is. There are fashions in headlines like anything else. Two very popular fads at present are 'X is a given fact, so why doesn't obvious corollary Y obtain?' and 'No, X isn't actually Y'. If I run across an article like this, I'm reluctant to submit it to HN because it's usually a low-quality piece of writing, and there's usually a better-quality that will appeal more to a technical audience.