4 ms·
These are not quite "true" monopolies however because the market for laundromats or car washes is still open to entry, i.e. contestable by others. The apparent
by zozbot234 4y ago
These are not quite "true" monopolies however because the market for laundromats or car washes is still open to entry, i.e. contestable by others. The apparent monopoly is in fact checked by the "virtual" competition that might be expected to appear if it becomes too inefficient. True monopolies are generally a product of real barriers to entry, which are indeed possible on the Internet. Reasonable users will be aware of this though, and prefer more open platforms where even prospective competitors are free to interoperate with the incumbent, and there's no undue lock-in.
The remaining obstacles amount to things like IP regulation, that can prevent entry even by a more open competitor.
- Retric 4y agoThe barriers to entry into a market with an existing laundromat, ignoring the setup costs, is the insufficient number of customers to support both until one of you fails. That’s what makes it a natural monopoly, you can’t have two business in stable compensation one of them will fail. Anyway, any market created monopoly will weaken once it loses it’s competitive edge. The run down movie theater may get driven out by a new cinema just as De Beers fell to from 80+% to sub 30% market share, but the barriers to entry are real.
- zozbot234 4y ago> That’s what makes it a natural monopoly, you can’t have two business in stable compensation one of them will fail. Yes it's a monopoly in that there's only one firm, but it won't behave much like one. Because the firm will be incented towards being a strong competitor towards any new entrants in the market, lest it be supplanted by them - even before those new entrants exist.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Retric 4y agoSure it’s always a question of the barriers to entry. However, the most effective barrier here is having a large bankroll to operate at a loss and drive competition out of the market. Which means charging monopoly prices just like every other monopoly.
- zozbot234 4y agoOperating at a loss can let you subsidize your market share, which might be a rational strategy if you're in a field with big network effects. Otherwise it won't help much, your competitors will simply not play that game. And the network effect case is one where you're actually creating value for your customer base - at least until an even more open competitor comes along. See how Compuserve, formerly a market-dominant walled garden benefiting from network effects, had to open themselves up to the Internet.
- Retric 4y agoI get your point, but not all monopolies form from network effects.
- WillPostForFood 4y agoA single laundromat in a small town isn't a monopoly because the business isn't "laundromats" it is washing clothes. They are in competition with washing machines, and, if need be, sinks.
- Retric 4y agoBy that argument the electric company isn’t a monopoly it’s in competition to people buying generators. In the end monopolies aren’t defined so abstractly because no business has absolutely exclusive control. Instead monopolies are defined by having monopoly power in the marketplace.