2 ms·
> but the FDA also compels them to say effectively "not that there is anything wrong with rBST". Source? Edit, found this. Wonder why this reasoning is not u
by lotsofpulp 4y ago
> but the FDA also compels them to say effectively "not that there is anything wrong with rBST".
Source?
Edit, found this. Wonder why this reasoning is not used for false implications in all the other labeling for supplements, vitamins, herbal, and organic food.
Even for milk, there is “A2” milk sold next to regular milk implying that A2 is somehow more nutritious, but it is not required to say “A1 milk has not been shown to be any worse than A2”.
https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/FR-1994-02-10/html/94-3214.htm https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/FR-1994-02-10/html/94-32...
> Because of the presence of natural bST in milk, no milk is
``bST-free,'' and a ``bST-free'' labeling statement would be false.
Also, FDA is concerned that the term ``rbST free'' may imply a
compositional difference between milk from treated and untreated
cows rather than a difference in the way the milk is produced.
Instead, the concept would better be formulated as ``from cows not
treated with rbST'' or in other similar ways. However, even such a
statement, which asserts that rbST has not been used in the
production of the subject milk, has the potential to be
misunderstood by consumers. Without proper context, such statements
could be misleading. Such unqualified statements may imply that milk
from untreated cows is safer or of higher quality than milk from
treated cows. Such an implication would be false and misleading.
>FDA believes such misleading implications could best be avoided
by the use of accompanying information that puts the statement in a
proper context. Proper context could be achieved in a number of
different ways. For example, accompanying the statement ``from cows
not treated with rbST'' with the statement that ``No significant
difference has been shown between milk derived from rbST-treated and
non-rbST-treated cows'' would put the claim in proper context.
Proper context could also be achieved by conveying the firm's
reasons (other than safety or quality) for choosing not to use milk
from cows treated with rbST, as long as the label is truthful and
nonmisleading.
- fmajid 4y agoWell, rBST is banned in the EU, non on health or safety but on animal welfare grounds, as cow udders are not made for that level of milk production and mechanical milking causes distress and injury (mastitis) to the cows. Also there is a difference between BST (bovine somatotropinnatural) and rBST (r stands for recombinant, the manufacturing process) the synthetic kind. The FDA's "concerns" are transparently based purely on the commercial interests of rBST producers like Monsanto and their customers'.