3 ms·
I don’t think vegetarians are really looking for Iron as Spinach provides as much as Meat. Meat substitutes are about flavor and mouth feel not nutrition, but
by Retric 4y ago
I don’t think vegetarians are really looking for Iron as Spinach provides as much as Meat.
Meat substitutes are about flavor and mouth feel not nutrition, but for those with excess iron (Hemochromatosis) I am sure they will appreciate the option. Which again shows how nutrition exists in context not isolation.
- rcme 4y agoThat study is in rats. Non-heme iron (i.e. the iron in spinach) has repeatedly been shown to be absorbed poorly in humans. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/8207546/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/8207546/ > ... studies have shown that the absorption of dietary nonheme iron in rats is much higher and less responsive to dietary variables than in human subjects.
- Retric 4y ago“(Bezwoda, Bothwell, Charlton et al.) the bioavailability of heme iron was measured to be about 20%, while the availability of non-heme iron varied between 6% and 18% depending on the amount of iron present in the meal.” Spinach has dramatically more Iron than Beef does so being absorbed at a lower ratio is offset by a much larger quantity of Iron being in the food.
- rcme 4y ago2.5X per unit weight… so the get the amount of iron in a 1/4 cheeseburger you’d need to eat 0.5-1 pounds of spinach. Possible, but hard.
- Retric 4y agoHow did you calculate that? If it’s got 2.5x as much and Bioavailability of iron in beef is ~20% and non beef ranges from 6% to 18% then… Worse case 2.5x * 0.06 / 0.20 = 75% as much per unit weight so you need 1/3 of a pound of Spinach. Best case was 2.5x * 0.18 / 0.2 = 225% so you need 1/9th of a pound. I am not saying your wrong, I just don’t get how you did that calculation.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- rcme 4y agoImagine a 1 lb steak contains N milligrams of of iron. After eating you'd absorb 0.2N milligrams. In 1 lb of spinach, there would be 2.5N milligrams of iron, and you'd absorb 6%, meaning you'd absorb (2.5 * 0.06)N milligrams, i.e. 0.15N milligrams. So clearly you need to eat more spinach to get the same amount of iron in the worst case. So you need to eat 33% more spinach in this case to get the same amount of iron. But some places list absorption of non-heme iron as low as 2%.