2 ms·
I have a car with many buttons[0] and a car with few buttons[1]. I'd take the few button one every time. While my few button car doesn't have many buttons, all
by vel0city 4y ago
I have a car with many buttons[0] and a car with few buttons[1]. I'd take the few button one every time.
While my few button car doesn't have many buttons, all to the critical to driving inputs have physical controls. Lights, wipers, defrosters, volume, etc is all on or immediately around the wheel.
Meanwhile, on my many button car, sure there's a button for most things this car can do. But almost all those buttons in the middle never get pressed. They're essentially a waste of space. And most of them, even if I were to press them I wouldn't be doing so while the car is in motion. I shouldn't be messing with the navigation system while the car is in motion. I shouldn't be flipping through folders on the mp3 CD or flash drive. I shouldn't be messing with the phone functions, I shouldn't be messing with the Blue link stuff, etc.
Having all those buttons aren't a positive while driving, they're a negative. They make the map I do use while driving much smaller. And when stopped, they make the Android Auto interface I interact with much smaller and overall worse.
Don't get me wrong, some manufacturers have gone way overboard and put things like glove compartments and AC vents and shifters on a screen or eliminated the stalks. There should be a balance for sure, but having a screen in a car is nice.
[0] https://www.autoguide.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2017/03/2017-Hyundai-Santa-Fe-Interior-696x426.jpg https://www.autoguide.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2017/03/20...
[1] https://www.macheforum.com/site/attachments/screen-shot-2021-01-31-at-5-18-24-pm-png.14226/ https://www.macheforum.com/site/attachments/screen-shot-2021...
- atoav 4y agoI don't think any person that wants physical interfaces (buttons, knobs, levers, sliders, ...) doesn't also think (touch-)screens can be nice for certain tasks. Being an electrical engineer there is one thing that I can tell you about electromechanical parts: They are expensive — especially in the good and reliable variant. That means car manufacturers have a real incentive to make you believe you don't need them and put everything on a touch screen instead.