3 ms·
I'd actually prefer people not do warrant canaries, and instead do conscientious periodic compliance reporting. Although a warrant canary sometimes suggests a
by neilv 4y ago
I'd actually prefer people not do warrant canaries, and instead do conscientious periodic compliance reporting.
Although a warrant canary sometimes suggests a very principled party (e.g., I first heard of public librarians doing it, decades ago), at the same time, it seems probably counterproductive.
For one example, as a customer of a service provider, I want them to be stable -- not potentially antagonizing those who could shut them down, nor getting involved in what (to me) seem like ambiguous technicalities over what they can and can't do.
For another example, imagine you run a service in which you've committed to a warrant canary. But one day a warrant comes, and you realize it's gravely important for the canary not to die and tip off some genocidal warlord you didn't realize was a customer. Now you're violating the canary assurance to your other customers, which is an assurance that you should've anticipated you couldn't give.
Alternative: Some of the modern compliance reporting by tech companies, about warrants/censorship/etc. seems less likely to cause showstopper problems, can convey more info, and is ongoing rather than single-shot.
Of course there will be warrants and other compliances, for various jurisdictions, and conscientious periodic reporting seems to help with civic checks&balances.
(BTW, I really like the idea of rsync.net and its hard-working founder, have pointed new customers to them, and have a TODO to move some stuff to them myself. The only proviso I've mentioned to people thus far is that there's an unclear bus factor.)
- SQueeeeeL 4y ago>I'd actually prefer people not do warrant canaries, and instead do conscientious periodic compliance reporting. The whole point of warrant canaries is that you can literally be compelled to silence under US law when dealing with intelligence organizations. It is impossible to state "The FBI has requested our data, all our users reporting on police brutality might wanna get off our platform" It might be legal to state "The FBI has never asked for our data", it might not, this hasn't been tested in court. They're not being hostile towards them, the CIA has literally arranged for multiple individuals to be assassinated, they should freak you out lol
- brookst 4y agoLots of companies report aggregate statistics[0]. I believe that’s what parent was advocating. 0. https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/21046081-google-geofence-warrants https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/21046081-google-geof...
- SQueeeeeL 4y agoThose documents are discussing warrants which don't have a gag order (I strongly believe, IANAL)
- brookst 4y agoI don’t believe gag orders preclude inclusion in a count like this, since that does not inform about the existence of a particular warrant. But I’d love to hear from someone more knowledgeable.
- neilv 4y agoIf we emulate the big kids, and only commit to do periodic compliance reporting only of what we can, when we can-- then we don't have to worry so much about stepping on the wrong toes. I'd guess in-house counsel could handle the day-to-day of this, looping in leadership when appropriate. That home government might also be a resource (not an adversary), such as if a difficult request comes from another government, and advice or diplomatic assistance is needed. No $5 wrenches nor soiled drawers necessary. No making assurances that you can't keep.
- patrakov 4y ago> It might be legal to state "The FBI has never asked for our data", it might not, this hasn't been tested in court. My opinion (beware, IANAL): by itself, stating this once, or as many times as one wants, is definitely legal. What's not tested is whether it's legal to give the promise to make such statements in the future with predictable periodicity.
- danaris 4y agoWhat, exactly, do you mean by "periodic compliance reporting"? If you mean reporting "we responded to X government subpoenas during this time," the whole point of a warrant canary is that the government can force you not to reveal that. If your main concern is the instantaneous removal of the canary once they've actually been served an NSL or whatever, then a) that's assuming that such a canary is, in fact, removed the moment they respond to such a government action, and b) seems to be positing fairly exotic situations, which are unlikely to be pertinent for the vast majority of cases where such a canary is being used.
- neilv 4y agoYes, I'm saying don't make yourself an adversary of your own government on this. And especially don't do it while predicating your entire strategy on a legal technicality game.
- danaris 4y agoI think there's ample evidence that a) If this is something that's going to be a problem, it'll be because the government has made itself your enemy, and b) the government's inability to compel speech is more than just a "legal technicality game".
- stetrain 4y agoWarrant canaries are a response to government orders that prevent transparent compliance reporting. In the US at least the government can order you to not reveal the existence of a warrant. They cannot (in theory) compel you to state that you have not received any such warrants. Thus the canary. I agree that being able to report on these activities transparently, even if it is done with a delay, would be preferable. But my understanding is that to accomplish that would require legislative changes to the current system.
- int_19h 4y agoThere's no shortage of services for those who don't need or want warrant canaries.