8 ms·
I wonder if monkey archeology will have artefacts described as being ‘for ritual use’?
by lostlogin 4y ago
I wonder if monkey archeology will have artefacts described as being ‘for ritual use’?
- ceejayoz 4y agoLandfills become "ceremonial mounds" filled with trinkets and household necessities for the afterlife.
- number6 4y agoThe site at Onkalo is still a mistery. One might suspect that the barrels are some kind of Sarkophagus. Surely a mighty warrior king was burried here with his troops
- atoav 4y agoI assume landfills have been much rarer in past times.
- RansomStark 4y agoEx-archaeologist here. You are correct, less people less trash, but you might be surprised. Archaeological landfills are called middens[0], and they're more like trash heaps than landfills, but there's a lot of them around the world. A quick primer from dig it Scotland on middens: https://www.digitscotland.com/a-load-of-old-rubbish-what-middens-can-reveal-about-scotlands-past/ https://www.digitscotland.com/a-load-of-old-rubbish-what-mid... [0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Midden https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Midden
- lostlogin 4y agoI’d assumed that a large part of it was that things were broadly biodegradable. Bone and pottery seems to be found, but a lot has rotted away. Near me there are a lot of middens and it’s just shells now, presumably from nearby Maori pa sites.
- zikduruqe 4y agoI am no expert, but I have always joked that instead of the Stone Age, it probably should be called the Wood Age. There were probably some awesome wooden structures or techniques that have been now lost to the ages because they are no longer around.
- Y_Y 4y agoGood point, bearing in mind that working wood with only stone and wooden tools is a lot harder than with metals
- naniwaduni 4y agoWorking, well, anything we're still going to see traces of would've been even harder harder with only stone and wooden tools than it would be to work wood. It seems pretty reasonable to guess that if we see a culture with stonework and pottery and access to wood, they probably also did stuff with the wood that hasn't survived. (We can then look for evidence, like tools that seems like they they make the most sense to be using for woodwork.)
- gus_massa 4y agoI'm not sure if it's correct, but I remember a tv show about archeology in East Asia, and they claimed that the problem is that they made too many tools of bamboo (that decompose) instead of tools of stone (that is forever).
- jimnotgym 4y agoNot picking on you, more on this kind if comment. I think it is easy to be snide about fields like archaeology when you come from a field of absolutisms and proofs, but what else are they supposed to do with gaps in knowledge? We don't have to approach CS work wondering if the 1s and 0s we found were naturally occurring, or put there by some level of intelligent being. Our field in entirely of human construction. The extension of this attitude leads to situations where Talib is berating a Classics professor for there being 'no data to back up her claim'! As if we can't study anything without data, or we should ignore history until there is something for a mathematician to work with on it. Perhaps we should poke fun at the physicists who talk about 'dark matter' in the same way. What a boring world it would be without shifting knowledge of the known and unknown.
- benj111 4y agoOn the other hand "I don't know" is a valid, and (should be) an acceptable answer. 'ritual use' is code for, I don't have a clue what practical use this thing could have. This isn't about known v unknown, it's about being intellectually honest and admitting the unknown.
- pyinstallwoes 4y agoI can’t know is what’s lacking from the zeitgeist. Too many people say I don’t know which implies they can. No, often it is can’t know.
- benj111 4y agoReally? What is the meaning of life? Where did the universe come from? Some of the most interesting questions are unanswerable / don't have a correct answer. In the field of archaeology there generally isn't the absolute 'can't know' though. Until the Rosetta stone came along we didn't know what various hieroglyphs meant. But the hypothetical existence, however remote of another Rosetta stone means we can know the answer to these various questions.
- 4y ago