3 ms·
I dont think modern culture is any more extractive than those that preceded it, we just have greater technology and capability. I think people have a bit a of a
by s1artibartfast 4y ago
I dont think modern culture is any more extractive than those that preceded it, we just have greater technology and capability. I think people have a bit a of a noble savage ideation for earlier times.
I agree that we have no idea what things will be like 1000 years from now. Verry little damage is irreversible on those timescales
- hinkley 4y agoThat's a Eurocentric view of history, and yes, that comes with a certain Noble Savage aspect. There are newer generations of books on indigenous peoples of North America. They still 'noble' it up a bit (the Lakota book in particular, which very carefully uses euphemisms for cannibalism). Robin Wall Kimerrer's books are easily the most romantic of the ones I've read. Tending the Wilds basically dismantles Muir's world view with a crowbar, and it's been a while but I don't remember if she even mentions Muir. It's very clear they are dismissing that same theory of California though. There were no primeval forests when Europeans arrived. It was all deeply curated and stewarded 'nature', heavily laden particularly with fire-adapted edible plants that the locals helped along if it had been too long since the last lightning storm took care of things. Nothing savage about it, debatably noble. Just a more animistic point of view and a bit more hedging against random acts of nature. We had some of that in europe too, but most of it was stamped out by the time Augustus became emperor. Written history is written by the victors. And the victors in Europe were agricultural+conqueror nations. Everything else got wiped out.