4 ms·
Well. No human rights are fundamental. They are all agreed upon rights that some nation states choose to respect and others don't. Even in states where these ri
by ThomPete 15y ago
Well. No human rights are fundamental. They are all agreed upon rights that some nation states choose to respect and others don't. Even in states where these rights are respected, violation is common.
So the question is not whether it is a human right, but whether it should be. And that is a decision only humans can make.
- wisty 15y agoIt's all about game theory. Nothing is really absolute - freedom of speech will always have limits. But it's important to tell the people that they do have absolute freedom of speech, otherwise what they have will be gradually eroded by seemingly reasonable steps. For example - you can't speak in favor of terrorist attacks, then a violent protest becomes classed as a terrorist attack, then a protest in which some participants are violent is a violent protest, then any protest might turn violent, then any public meeting which disparages the government becomes classed as a protest. Suddenly, you can't criticize the government, or you're a terrorist. It's far better to say you have absolute freedom of speech, and hope everyone turns a bit of a blind eye when the really crazy stuff gets silenced. That way, if too much stuff is getting banned, people will push back.
- 27182818284 15y agoThe amount of time on this planet where there has been no agreement to the "fundamental" rights that people in the US now speak of vastly dwarfs the age of the US. There is nothing historically fundamental about them. They are "fundamental" only in the sense that in the last few centuries they grew in popularity