2 ms·
He wasn't technically wrong if you include the part where he said "unless population growth stops". The OP then lists all the ways in which people tried to do
by ZeroGravitas 4y ago
He wasn't technically wrong if you include the part where he said "unless population growth stops".
The OP then lists all the ways in which people tried to do that in authoritarian ways (without much impact) and how it happened anyway due to various factors that Ehrlich can't take credit for.
But it still happened, so "If not X then Y" can still be true even when X does and Y doesn't happen.
I also feel the degrowth stuff is just people talking past each other.
The article he links to suggest more public transport, better insulated homes and eating healthier plant based diets are examples of "degrowth" and there's no way for government to achieve these wild goals. Well, maybe they could stop subsidizing the opposite of those at the very least.