4 ms·
Modern roads are designed to take serious abuse. 50 years of load cycling 20 ton semi at highway speeds causes mechanical damage which Roman concrete wouldn’t
by Retric 4y ago
Modern roads are designed to take serious abuse. 50 years of load cycling 20 ton semi at highway speeds causes mechanical damage which Roman concrete wouldn’t be effective in preventing. In ancient sites you can sometimes see the walls in high traffic areas have gotten smoothed and indented from hundreds of years worth of people gently dragging their fingertips across the surface as they walk by, tires are less gentile.
Also, people vastly underestimate how cheap road surfaces need to be. Try and calculate the volume of material making up the US road system.
- JanSolo 4y agoI live in Montreal; many of the concrete structures in my city are crumbling and decaying due to the constant freeze/thaw temperature cycling that they're exposed to. I wonder if the self-healing property of this new advanced concrete would help to avoid some of the cracking & flaking we're seeing in constructions from the 60s & 70s.
- kibwen 4y agoOnly if you take out the rebar. Concrete is porous, water penetrates to the rebar inside, the rebar rusts and expands, cracking the concrete. But if you remove the rebar, you remove much of the tensile strength of the structure, which means you need to use way more concrete to compensate (via the sheer compressive force of its own weight).
- elzbardico 4y agoWhat about those new materials for rebar? Like fiberglass? What do you think of them?
- bombela 4y agoNot the parent. My understanding is metal rebar is the cheapest. You need a lot of rebar in modern concrete construction.
- betaby 4y agoI live in Montreal too, and while all what you say is true ... the same is not true for the xUSSR cold cities I lived before immigration. So quality makes difference. Also planing and designing for less maintenance. Concrete structures from the same era across xUSSR are in way better shape.
- newsclues 4y agoMontreal has infrastructure problems because of systemic corruption with the local Mafia. To think that the USSR had better infrastructure (less corruption) than modern day corrupt places like Montreal is a brutal shock.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- magicpin 4y agoA fun exercise is to calcualte the cost of some road in a neighboorhood, and compare that to the total collected property tax of all the homes along that road.
- mikeyouse 4y agoA relative of mine who's otherwise a smart guy was lamenting rural broadband as an Obama boondoggle since it's never going to pay for itself to run fiber to all of the remote communities in our state... he didn't want to hear about the "P&L" for the road capital/maintenance costs.
- nemo44x 4y agoThen multiple that by 20 (the lifetime of the road surface) and factor in that the resurfacing is significantly cheaper than the initial build and you quickly find roads are easily subsidized by property taxes.
- dwater 4y agoEven in rural areas? Even if we add in the cost of maintaining infrastructure that runs under the road surface (water, sewer, and gas)?
- eppp 4y agoI live in a very rural area and I had a few minutes so I calculated it. I live at the end of a deadend road that is 0.9 miles off another very rural road. The road is chip sealed, which according to google in 2022 is $25,000 to $42,000 per mile. There are 7 parcels that collect $6396 per year in property taxes. At the low end of the chip seal price, it would take 3.53 years to pay it off and 5.9 years at the high end. This assumes that no sales or gas taxes are used to fund any of the road construction, which isn't true.
- nemo44x 4y ago> (water, sewer, and gas)? Over their lifetime, easily. The pipes for those will last 100 years, easily. The maintenance of them are paid for by the delivery costs you pay in your bill. As for rural I think there's 2 distinctions. 1 is we need rural communities because they produce our food and other things. Secondly, rural areas are between 2 or more populated areas. We need to connect populated areas so by necessity there are roads. Rural communities are built off of those. The other distinction where you may be closer is exuburban communities built into rural areas. These may or may not be fully covered. Not initially anyways, but you'd assume the property taxes would cover in time.