4 ms·
The government is run by and for the benefit of the established land owners and they don't want housing, they want excess returns. Simple.
by jeffbee 4y ago
The government is run by and for the benefit of the established land owners and they don't want housing, they want excess returns. Simple.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> government is run by and for the benefit of the established land owners Do San Francisco’s renters fail to turn out to vote? (Serious question.)
- akavi 4y agoI don't know about SF in particular, but nationwide, yes, renters turn out to vote at a far lower rate than homeowners[0] (67% vs 49%) [0] https://www.apartmentlist.com/research/renter-voting-preferences https://www.apartmentlist.com/research/renter-voting-prefere...
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> nationwide, yes, renters turn out to vote at a far lower rate than homeowners Wider than I expected. Thank you. Asking because in New York, renters turn out, and that drives policy outcomes. (They’re also less likely to think supply and demand is a myth.)
- mrguyorama 4y agoBy and large, poorer people vote less than wealthy people. It is harder to vote in america as a poorer person in many areas, arguably on purpose.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> harder to vote in america as a poorer person in many areas, arguably on purpose Is this true in San Francisco?
- mrguyorama 4y agoUnfortunately at this point, you've reached the end of my knowledge. I assume California has reasonable mail in voting procedures. That should make the "cost" of voting very very minimal. Do we still see poor people voting less there? I don't know actually.
- t-writescode 4y agoAlternative question: * do San Francisco renters turn out to Town Hall meetings, local elections, pester their representatives and put in as much #not-bribery as landowners?
- BigRedDog1669 4y agoTown Hall type meetings only take curated questions normally and heavily gatekeep who is allowed to speak.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> Town Hall type meetings only take curated questions normally and heavily gatekeep who is allowed to speak Then it’s not a town hall. Town hall means anyone can ask questions. You may need to line up. But that’s it.
- jeffbee 4y agoYes, they very much do. The voter turnout gap by housing tenure is about 20 percentage points (e.g. 70% turnout for owners and 50% for renters). Also the voter registration gap is massive because many renters are not eligible to vote or face hurdles registering due to lack of permanent address. Finally, the people who would benefit from new housing construction in a place like San Francisco are often registered to vote in some other jurisdiction. The people who already live in S.F. have no particular compelling interest in a new apartment tower, but the prospective tenants of those apartments who would vote for them aren't all voters in that city.
- SAI_Peregrinus 4y agoAnd lower income people are far more likely to be renters than landowners. Lower income jobs are less likely to provide time off to vote. Even if mail-in voting is allowed such low-income jobs are also less likely to provide time off to attend city council meetings or public hearings or other such things.
- jeffbee 4y agoYup. Census data shows that non voters with incomes less than $20k/year give transportation issues as the reason in 8% of cases, but only 0.1% of people with incomes over $100k give this reason.
- closeparen 4y agoTo the extent that SF renters are organized, they're organized around groups and ideologies that don't prioritize supply a solution. They're focused on things like rent control, just cause eviction, foreign/institutional investor boogeymen, and preventing even substantially or fully below-market housing developments because they still threaten to upset what renters believe is a delicate balance their neighborhoods/communities depend on. It makes sense, renters who are politically engaged and organized are more likely to be long-term residents, and being able to preserve your tenancy/community is a different thing from being able to easily move or upgrade.
- prottog 4y ago> They're focused on things like rent control, just cause eviction, foreign/institutional investor boogeymen, and preventing even substantially or fully below-market housing developments Which is funny, since every single thing here makes the situation worse, because it ensures that new developments will be more expensive and riskier.
- tick_tock_tick 4y ago> Do San Francisco’s renters fail to turn out to vote? They aren't the best but when thy do vote they've somehow managed to link voting for housing to being a form a racist gentrification.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- rsj_hn 4y agoSan Francisco has a large transient population of renters. They drift in, party and work hard, and then leave when they have kids or want to settle down. This is because San Francisco is not very family friendly - it's a city with more dogs than kids -- with more drug addicts than kids. It's much more of a party town than a place where people can put down roots. The average renter lives in San Francisco for 6 years and then moves away. Don't think of San Francisco as a self-contained unit, it is a 7x7 mile square containing 800K people in a larger SF Bay Area containing 8 million people. People go to the Square when they are in the mid to late 20s to early 30s to party and then move to other places nearby when they have a family. This transient population generally does not involve itself too much in local issues because it is not attached to city. That is why SF mayoral candidates and city council candidates spend a lot more time discussing how they will fight global warming and white supremacy rather than discussing local zoning. Because the transient population cares about these general non-local issues and generally don't bother too much with details of local issues. This has some hilarious consequences, for example, one rich family whose view would get blocked by new development managed to put on the ballot a measure to block the development, and got it to pass in the name of "Save our Waterfront From Greedy Corporations". That's why SF has a large parking lot and tennis courts on prime waterfront real estate. There is no one easier to manipulate than the uninformed do-gooders that is the SF voting population -- just link more housing development to "greedy corporations" or "gentrification" or "large carbon footprint" or complain about lack of diversity in the construction crew or administrative staff, or new residents, etc. So many ways to kill a project. The result is that control over local issues -- e.g. what the city council actually does -- is handed over to a small core of residents that do care and have put down roots -- e.g. to homeowners. And homeowners want house prices to rise and for neighborhoods to not change radically. Therefore the SF city council and mayor are very conservative about things like zoning, even as they spend a lot of time espousing radical positions on generic lefty issues.
- jeffbee 4y agoCongratulations on squeezing every toxic canard about "transient" renters into a single comment! According to the Census American Community Survey of 2021, 43% of renters in San Francisco have lived in the same dwelling for ten years or more. It certainly is not typical that a person arrives and departs the city in just 6 years.
- rr888 4y agoThat really make sense because if you own land high density buildings make land much more valuable.
- jjav 4y ago> The government is run by and for the benefit of the established land owners and they don't want housing, they want excess returns. Simple. Simple but simplistic, that's just a caricature. Reality is more complex, and regular homeowners don't care about returns, excess or otherwise. People buy homes to live in, to raise their kids in and to maybe retire in if health allows. Most people enjoy stability, so it's nice for the neighborhood to change slowly or not that much.