3 ms·
How about the right to own a printing press? A bit of not so distant nostalgia to consider: in some totalitarian states in 20th century (up to late 70's in one
by eternalban 15y ago
How about the right to own a printing press? A bit of not so distant nostalgia to consider: in some totalitarian states in 20th century (up to late 70's in one case I am aware of first hand), access to mimeograph machines were restricted.
Of course, he is correct that the actual right is the right to free speech, but practically considered in context of modern life, the two are arguably effectively equivalent as simply denying access effectively curtails the inherent right.
And what to make of the speakers' corner in Hyde Park? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Speakers_corner http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Speakers_corner
- andrewfelix 15y ago>"How about the right to own a printing press?" Wouldn't the equivalent be owning an ISP in that case? I think a better analogy might be the right to own and read a book. Which is pretty a pretty fucking important right.
- VMG 15y agoBoth are bad analogies, because owning a book or a printing press is not dependent on third parties after an initial transaction. Having an internet connection is per definition dependent on somebody providing the connection.
- eternalban 15y ago> owning .. a printing press is not dependent on third parties after an initial transaction. Consider: - You have the right to "bear arms" but "you do not have a right to purchase bullets". - You have the right to "free press" but "you do not have a right to purchase ink".
- paganel 15y ago> How about the right to own a printing press? A bit of not so distant nostalgia to consider: in some totalitarian states in 20th century (up to late 70's in one case I am aware of first hand), access to mimeograph machines were restricted. In Ceausescu's Romania in the 1980s if you had a typewriter you had to declare it to the local police, so in order to avoid all the hassle of dealing with the police, or even the Securitate (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Securitate http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Securitate), you'd just forget about it and carry on with living your daily life, freedom of expression be damned. Also, Romanians were very frustrated by lack of TV air-time, by the end of the 1980s the Romanian national television was only airing 2 hours per day, mostly filled with bullshit propaganda. During the 1989 December revolt lots of people actually complained about that out loud. It would be interesting to see what happens if SOPA (or any related law) actually has a similar effect on Americans' access to the web, will they complain on the streets?
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- eternalban 15y agoI'm not sure if you an immigrant to US, as I am. It is perhaps not surprising that naturalized Americans who have fled to US precisely for "liberty" and know first hand what a tyranny looks like, are more sensitive to these matters than the native born citizens who have come to take many of these matters for granted. I must tell you it is very frustrating. Where to go now, if we don't roll back these clearly authoritarian steps (Patriot Act, NDAA, and now SOPA) in America? (Please don't tell me to move to Canada!)
- paganel 15y ago> I'm not sure if you an immigrant to US, as I am. Fortunately, I'm not :) I still live in Romania. I do work for a small startup who is owned by 3 Americans though, and I don't even bother to tell them how fucked up this all looks, they all know it. Another related and not-so-cool story was when I went to London and when I saw all those surveillance cameras literally invading the whole city. Guys like Ceausescu or Stalin would have given their right arm to have that kind of tech at their disposal, but instead there I was, in the land of the Magna Carta being surveilled and monitored like not even my parents were during the ruling of a communist dictator. It's not even funny anymore.