6 ms·
A Curious Integral
- hk__2 4y agoAs a non-math person I didn’t understand anything, but I enjoyed reading just for the enthusiasm of the author.
- pipingdog 4y agoIf you want to get a flavor of the article without being too much of a math person, you can watch the 3Blue1Brown video linked in the article, which captures a similar surprise that for certain values a formula maps exactly to a "round" quantity, then starts to diverge after a while. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=851U557j6HE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=851U557j6HE
- schlauerfox 4y agoMy ignorant intuition is since it's the area between sin(x)/x and the x axis, but as you get further into infinity the 1/x still keeps getting smaller slowly but sin(x) always is the same magnitude, the integral gets slightly further away the closer you get to infinity and that slight difference adds up?
- hgsgm 4y agoYes but the question is why the value is exact for small N.
- kragen 4y agothat borwein integral formula is one of the first things baez mentions
- dysoco 4y agoI wondered if the Greg Egan he named provided a comment on the integral was THE Greg Egan (author of Permutation City) and following the comment indeed he was!
- spindle 4y agoIIRC, THE Greg Egan has a (genuinely excellent, peer-reviewed) maths paper with John Baez, and a number of smaller or unpublished contributions to professional maths.
- wyager 4y agoYes, Greg is an active math guy. You can often find comments from Greg, John Baez, and Scott on each other's blogs. They are some of my favorite bloggers/writers!
- anthk 4y agoI was about to say this.
- deepspace 4y agoI have been fascinated by these integrals for a long time and am happy to see them getting more attention. 3Blue1Brown recently made a video on the topic: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=851U557j6HE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=851U557j6HE What strikes me is the reminder that it is never possible to "prove" something by pointing out that it is true for all known cases. (See also Black Swan events). In Greg Egan's example, if you stopped testing at 10^43 iterations, you would be very tempted to conclude that the identity holds for all n, for example.
- _nalply 4y agoTo prove something for all n you need to do mathematical induction: First prove that something is true for some n, usually n = 1. Then prove that if it's true for n it's for n + 1, too. Boom. It's true for all n. But the second step is sometimes very hard or even perhaps impossible.
- Chinjut 4y agoInduction is one way to prove something for all n but hardly the only way.
- galaxyLogic 4y ago> Then prove that if it's true for n it's for n + 1, too. Or you might be able to prove that it is true for n + 2 but not be able to prove it is true for n + 1. Right?
- c7b 4y ago> What strikes me is the reminder that it is never possible to "prove" something by pointing out that it is true for all known cases. Not exactly true. If you can prove that the cases you checked amount to all the cases in the theorem statement, you're done. The Four-color theorem is a well-known example that was originally proved in this way (accompanied by a controversy about whether that's a 'real' proof, which is arguably pretty much settled at this point). Induction would arguably be another way (that only requires checking a single case).
- w10-1 4y agoIt seems like an exercise in mathematical self-absorption, but it's really a fundamental question for science: assuming you have equations and even a model of the world that is really, really close, is that any kind of proof? And even if math/logic is granted its perfect world, it's never even self-complete. Welcome back to the world of practical wisdom, where the rest of us live and work :)
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- hintymad 4y agoIt's always heartwarming to see people passionately geek out, seeking to advance our civilization. It's also curious that a land of geeks like the US would have a culture of looking down upon geeks, to the point that Paul Graham would write essays like Why Nerds Are Unpopular[1]. I couldn't even understand that essay when reading it for the first time, as it was a novel concept in my country that people didn't appreciate hardworking and passion in hard subjects. It's even stranger that Americans thought it was a great virtual to toil in sports, like shooting hoops thousands of times a day, but it was a sin to toil in STEM, like solving maths problems for fun. But well, it's a topic for another day. [1] http://www.paulgraham.com/nerds.html http://www.paulgraham.com/nerds.html. Quote: "I know a lot of people who were nerds in school, and they all tell the same story: there is a strong correlation between being smart and being a nerd, and an even stronger inverse correlation between being a nerd and being popular. Being smart seems to make you unpopular."
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- tom-thistime 4y agoA lot of good points here. Another possible lesson from these integrals: if someone has deliberately prepared the problem you're studying, and made it misleading on purpose, then solving the problem may be a different game from studying a problem that arose for some other reason.
- heliophobicdude 4y agoVery similar to Cunningham's Law. https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Cunningham%27s_Law https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Cunningham%27s_Law
- singularity2001 4y agoIt reminds me of those 'surprising' rational approximations of π where xyz/abc≈π with 7 digits precision and abcd/efgh≈π with 9 digits precision. It's not that surprising when you take into account that abcd/efgh does not save you many digits compared to just writing π out. Somewhat similarly the ±23 chars of "∫ 0 ∞ cos(2x)∏ n 1 ∞ cos(xn)dx" giving 43 digits of another number is not _that_ surprising and in the realm of what you can expect with some likelihood. I expect that one could theoretically find some double integral with less then 25 signs which approximates e^π or ANY number to 50 digits. Now if you find some 20 char expression which approximates another 20 char expression up to 100000 digits and THEN suddenly takes a different turn, that would be really curious. Like those properties of natural numbers which are true for some orders of magnitude before someone found a counter example.
- version_five 4y agoFrom the article: Jaded nonmathematicians told us it’s just a coincidence, so what is there to explain? The actual reason they get into is interesting and much deeper and orthogonal to the information content of the representation
- Jabbles 4y ago(1+9^-4(6*7))^3^2^85 is an expression that uses all digits 1-9 once and approximates e to 10^25 digits. https://math.stackexchange.com/questions/1945026/an-amazing-approximation-of-e https://math.stackexchange.com/questions/1945026/an-amazing-...
- cozzyd 4y agoyeah but that's silly since lim n->\infty (1 + \frac{1}{n})^ n is even easier to remember
- wyager 4y agoThis one isn't so interesting, as it's super easy to generate `e` in lots of different ways (such as the limit the expression is approximating). `e` is a very low-kolmogorov-complexity constant. The error term in the integral, on the other hand, has no apparent reason to be.
- tomrod 4y agoI have a social group of folks that work out hard integrals via social media -- friends and friends of friends over the years in quant jobs and graduate school where we work on fun things. This author obviously knows this at a deeper level, especially the academic literature, where our group is more raw about it. So fun. Thanks to the author and the poster for a pleasant Friday afternoon read.
- dxbydt 4y ago> I have a social group of folks that work out hard integrals via social media Heh heh! Glad am not the only one. I used to think this was purely an Asian habit, borne out of excessive focus on math problems during the 11-12 grades in order to pass the grueling entrance exams. I mostly share pdfs of math problems with former classmates thru linkedin.
- chrisshroba 4y agoAny chance I could get in on this? Sounds like a lot of fun and I love chatting about interesting math problems and meeting like-minded folks!
- dxbydt 4y agoWell, I live in the midwest, a small republican town in flyover country, with no fancypants private schools nearby :) The kids here go to public school. I thought I can help them out. So I volunteered my "math services" to the public school teachers & set up a side project website, weekly 1-1 math sessions. Long story short - this year three 6th graders I work with ended up acing the AMC 10, which is a contest that American kids take in the 10th grade. One of them even made the AIME cutoff, which is the top 1% i.e. top 3000 of the 300,000 contestants. So I'm thinking of increasing my efforts in that direction. Maybe host a math contest forum for working adults where we can work on interesting integrals & suchlike :) Lemme know what you think, perhaps we can collab.
- hgsgm 4y ago
- kloch 4y agoCoincidences are everywhere in math and physics, but our monkey brains just can't accept that they are meaningless.
- olddustytrail 4y agoYour post is meaningless. Where else does meaning exist other than within a brain?
- yarg 4y agoDude, this isn't a cloud that looks like a dinosaur. It's a low complexity integral whose value matches pi/8 to 41 decimal places. Of course it's not a coincidence.
- marshray 4y agoI counted the number of symbols in the equation after "As far as I can tell, the known proofs that"... It contained 41 letters and other miscellaneous math symbols. Therefore, I find it unsurprising that it generates a specific constant having a magnitude of 10^-43. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kolmogorov_complexity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kolmogorov_complexity
- civilized 4y agoWell I hope it wouldn't be too different in French then!
- abetusk 4y agoI only skimmed the article and skipped to the 3Brown1Blue [0] video which I found very enlightening. Basically, the tldr version is that product under the integral can be considered a sum, of sorts, in the Fourier domain (convolution <-> product and products turn into sums under some transformation of exponentiation) and when the coefficients of that sum cross a constant, then the original integral becomes less than pi. That is, when $\sum_{i=0}^n \frac{1}{2 i + 1} >= 1$, that's the transition point. 15 in the denominator is where that sum is greater than one. Awesome stuff. [0] https://youtu.be/851U557j6HE https://youtu.be/851U557j6HE
- spindle 4y agoGreat summary explanation - thank you!
- quickthrower2 4y agoThat video is excellent and I wish they existed when I studied mathematics years ago as I may have kept going! In particular he gives the broad overview first so you understand it at a squint level and then you feel motivated to learn more. Vs. turning up at “Convolutions 101” lecture and having a lemma written on the board. This sort of math is my favourite advanced mathematics. I never enjoyed stats and I never enjoyed anything more abstract I could not visualize.
- amai 4y agoIn my opinion the most curious integrals are the https://mathworld.wolfram.com/WatsonsTripleIntegrals.html https://mathworld.wolfram.com/WatsonsTripleIntegrals.html . „However, to obtain an entirely closed form, it is necessary to do perform some analytic wizardry (see Watson 1939 for details). The fact that a closed form exists at all for this integral is therefore rather amazing.“
- ForOldHack 4y agoIf these two integrals differ, then you can subtract one from the other, and plot an error function. You would need a bit more storage than a difference engine, and a lot more accuracy than current computational methods.
- rudolfwinestock 4y agoEntire books have been written about curious integrals. Irresistible Integrals: Symbolics, Analysis and Experiments in the Evaluation of Integrals, by George Boros https://www.amazon.com/dp/0521796369/ https://www.amazon.com/dp/0521796369/ Inside Interesting Integrals, by Paul J. Nahin https://www.amazon.com/Inside-Interesting-Integrals-Substitutions-Undergraduate-ebook/dp/B08BZ767Y2 https://www.amazon.com/Inside-Interesting-Integrals-Substitu...