4 ms·
I think what they are arguing is looking at aggregate usage isn’t important if that water wouldn’t flow into the lake. We also have this disconnect in the deba
by jeffbee 4y ago
I think what they are arguing is looking at aggregate usage isn’t important if that water wouldn’t flow into the lake.
We also have this disconnect in the debate around water in California. You could stop watering every almond grove in the state and that wouldn’t change anything about major urban water supplies, because the watersheds aren’t related.
- lazide 4y agoMost of the issues with the Great Salt Lake are directly due to diverting water for agricultural, industrial, and residential use - in that order. See figure 5. From the paper “ Agriculture dominates water use in the Great Salt Lake watershed (Fig. 5)25,26,69. Irrigation of alfalfa and other crops directly accounts for around three quarters of total consumptive water use…” Agricultural diversions of stream water that would otherwise go to the Great Salt Lake account for 74% of the water used. Industrial and mining, 18%, evaporation 8%, and cities and residential use 8%. This isn’t like California. [https://www.researchgate.net/publication/366876763_Emergency_measures_needed_to_rescue_Great_Salt_Lake_from_ongoing_collapse https://www.researchgate.net/publication/366876763_Emergency...]
- AnimalMuppet 4y agoYeah, as lazide said, this is different. All the water for Salt Lake City, Ogden, Provo, and suburbs (plus agriculture in Salt Lake, Utah, Davis, Weber, and Summit counties) would flow into the Great Salt Lake. It's all the same watershed. Next question: Does anyone have statistics on how much of the precipitation in that watershed is due to the "lake effect"? (For those not in the know: When storms cross the Great Salt Lake, they pick up evaporation, which increases the precipitation of the storms when they get to the Wasatch Mountains. That precipitation then flows - or would flow, if not diverted - back into the lake.) If the lake dries up, so does the lake effect. That could reduce the amount of precipitation that we get. If it's a major effect, it could be big trouble for the environment and the economy.
- lazide 4y agoBased on the paper, and some other comments I ran across [https://www.mdpi.com/2225-1154/7/5/67 https://www.mdpi.com/2225-1154/7/5/67], it has to be pretty negligible overall. Evaporation has been decreasing as salinity increases and surface area have been shrinking, and total precipitation has been staying roughly the same. Which makes sense - most inflows are via precipitation on several large mountain ranges nearby (and relatively infrequent storms), and unless air movement was limited/locked to be solely within the great salt lake basin (in which case precipitation should be noticeably dropping, but it isn’t), the air volumes from daily evaporation would only rarely overlap with the air volumes causing the large rain and snow storms in the mountains. Definitely still some effect though! And worth asking about for sure: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Salt_Lake_effect https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Salt_Lake_effect