7 ms·
Please Sell My Personal Information
- rpastuszak 4y agoRecently I contacted Citi bank which kept sending me spam, including "bank statements" I could not access, which makes perfect sense given that I don't have an account with them. I was told that they had no record of me and that if I want to be super duper sure they're right I should send a physical letter with a scan of my Id to their offices. After another few months of getting spammed by them, I sent them a GDPR data subject request instead. After a few days I received a message stating that: 1) my email was removed from their mailing list (yay) 2) they didn't/process have any of my personal data, but 3) since I shared my personal data with them _via the data subject request_, they're obliged to keep it I'm not angry, I just enjoy the irony and absurdity of the entire situation. In a sense, large orgs like this are as coherent as GPT-3 is away of what it's talking about.
- surprisetalk 4y agoThe exact same kafkaesque situation is what inspired me to write this post! I don't want to send my personal information in a "delete my personal info" form to organizations who I never trusted with my data in the first place
- nugget 4y agoDozens of new privacy laws have been passed in the last few years. In some cases, there are now severe financial penalties associated with non-compliance. This has started to empower internal teams within companies (who want to do the right thing) to actually do the right thing, and follow both the letter and spirit of these laws. I'm part of a project to build a global "delete me" button so I have insight into a range of different responses. Most companies still tend to be maliciously compliant or they simply ignore the request, but I'd be comfortable sending them my data. There are definitely bad actors out there for whom you're probably better off not sending them any request at all. Progress is slow but it's headed in the right direction.
- surprisetalk 4y agoThank you for the insight! I think a lot of people would be interested in a global "delete me" button. Where can I get updates on your project?
- chadd 4y agoin all seriousness, i'll take the contrary opinion, i love targeted ads. saves me time, and there's no way to keep my data private anyway, so i might as well get some value out of it. i wish there were a browser plugin called "please accept all cookies" which would just get rid of the friction, and as a downstream fringe benefit, show me better ads.
- benmanns 4y agoThis browser extension doesn't work everywhere, but it works some places. You can auto-decline all cookie prompts, or if you're so inclined, auto-accept: https://github.com/cavi-au/Consent-O-Matic https://github.com/cavi-au/Consent-O-Matic
- NJRBailey 4y agoI agree - I mostly get ads for things I'm actually interested in (e.g. furniture), and I don't usually buy anything from them, but it at least makes me aware that there may be a new style of products available for when I next need to make a purchase. Also on occasion there will be an advert for something which I wasn't aware existed, or which shows me a new idea to consider. I'm also happy to see ads as an alternative to having to pay for access to a site.
- masterof0 4y agoThen it should be opt-in. You are free to post your personal info online.
- dmitriid 4y ago> and there's no way to keep my data private anyway This is learned helplessness. Instead of giving up we should mete multi(m|b)illion fines to corporations who think that your data is theirs https://noyb.eu/en/breaking-meta-prohibited-use-personal-data-advertising https://noyb.eu/en/breaking-meta-prohibited-use-personal-dat...
- avalys 4y agoIn this context, "my personal information" really means "Your records of my interactions with your company", right?
- advisedwang 4y agoThey mention credit history, so lets take financial records as an example. Technically the complete list of things you have purchased is a record of interactions with your bank, but I think it's incredibly privacy violating for a bank to sell infomation about what products I buy. Technically the docs to prepare a tax return is a now a record of an interaction with turbotax, but I don't think Intuit should be able to sell infomation about where I work, what charities I've donated too or what investments I have. Being a "record of an interaction with a company" doesn't give the company the right to do what they want with it.
- drusepth 4y ago>Technically the complete list of things you have purchased is a record of interactions with your bank, but I think it's incredibly privacy violating for a bank to sell infomation about what products I buy. Isn't it in almost every bank's ToS that they are not only allowed to do this, but expected to do this? TBH, I wouldn't be surprised to hear about Intuit selling my financial data, either.
- dublinben 4y agoBanks in the US are required to provide a standardized privacy statement about what personal information they share, and whether you can limit it. There are meaningful differences between banks, so it's not at all true that "almost every bank" is as anti-consumer as possible. Some examples showing differences: https://www.td.com/content/dam/tdb/document/pdf/personal-banking/privacy-shareinformation-en.pdf https://www.td.com/content/dam/tdb/document/pdf/personal-ban... https://www.chase.com/digital/resources/privacy-security/privacy/consumer-privacy-notice https://www.chase.com/digital/resources/privacy-security/pri... https://www.usaa.com/inet/wc/privacy_promise https://www.usaa.com/inet/wc/privacy_promise https://www.goldmansachs.com/privacy-and-cookies/Apple_Card_Privacy_Policy.pdf https://www.goldmansachs.com/privacy-and-cookies/Apple_Card_... https://online.citi.com/JRS/popups/ao/Citibank_Consumer_Privacy_Notice.pdf https://online.citi.com/JRS/popups/ao/Citibank_Consumer_Priv...
- jonstaab 4y agoIs this an excerpt from Faust?
- pbreit 4y agoI cannot believe we are still in this ridiculous situation with these dreadful cookie approvals on Every. Single. Page. How did we let Europe do this to us?
- Sebb767 4y ago> How did we let Europe do this to us? Blaming the EU for this feels pretty disingenuous. GDPR is definitely well-intentioned and in the interest of the consumers, the horribly annoying popups you get everywhere are just a form of malicious compliance from companies who want to track you anyway and make opting out as annoying as possible. Note that it's perfectly fine to have a page without a cookie popup. HN doesn't have one, for example. It's just not in the interest of companies to forgo user tracking.
- sneak 4y agoLaws that allow malicious compliance are bad laws. Intentions should not be a factor in evaluating whether laws are good laws or not. GDPR is not a good law. It hasn't even put a dent in the problem, and we are worse off for having it.
- mindslight 4y agoObtaining "consent" via nagwalls and other dark patterns doesn't seem like its actually legal per the GDPR. Rather the enforcement is just so slow moving that it appears that way. So your complaint seems akin to saying that the laws against physical assault are pointless, because you were attacked and the police didn't find your assailant.
- sneak 4y agoGDPR has had a huge cost. If it doesn't yield any benefit because it's not being enforced, then it is a bad law, because it has costs without benefit, unlike the prohibition on physical assault, which is "free".
- temp2022account 4y agoThis has been my approach for the last 10 years: I live to make adversisers pay out the nose for my attention, then I don't buy products. I'll fill out surveys, invent names as long as the terms are vague enough to allow it, and do anything in my power to give large data-miners as much information to choke on as possible. I personally think the best way to fix online advertising is to make it so expensive that door-to-door salesman suddenly make financial sense.
- jeroenhd 4y agoThis is exactly why I like the concept behind AdNauseam, the UBlock Origin fork that will click every single ad it encounters (but still hide the actual ads). I'm sure advertisers have had to invest into detection algorithms because of that addon. Edit: links: - Website: https://adnauseam.io/ https://adnauseam.io/ - Addon for Firefox: https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/adnauseam/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/adnauseam/ - Addon for Edge: https://microsoftedge.microsoft.com/addons/detail/adnauseam/mlojlfildnehdpnlmpkeiiglhhkofhpb https://microsoftedge.microsoft.com/addons/detail/adnauseam/... - Source and instructions for installing on Chrome: https://github.com/dhowe/AdNauseam https://github.com/dhowe/AdNauseam Note that Google removed AdNauseam from their Chrome Store for interfering with their ad business. The fact they removed AdNauseam but not uBlock Origin is a good sign that the addon is doing something right!
- surprisetalk 4y agohttps://adnauseam.io https://adnauseam.io
- lcnPylGDnU4H9OF 4y ago> Note that Google removed AdNauseam from their Chrome Store for interfering with their ad business. No, you misunderstand, they removed it from their store because extensions are supposed to "have a single purpose that is clear to users"[0]. /s [0] https://adnauseam.io/free-adnauseam.html https://adnauseam.io/free-adnauseam.html (third paragraph)
- verisimi 4y ago
- garganzol 4y agoI am one of those few who loves ads. Some banners catch my attention to the point that I start analyzing the design and marketing choices made by their creators. I save the most outstanding banners to my hard drive to enjoy them later. Is this a full-blown pathology or just an eccentric kink? Who knows, but the presented sarcastic article resonates with me. Needless to say, I watch hours of YouTube videos full of ads from the 80s and 90s. I just can't get enough of them.
- surprisetalk 4y agoWoah! I'm genuinely curious what kind of things you've collected over the years! If it's not too much trouble, could you send me a dump of everything? or just your favorites? Sounds like a fun rabbit-hole :) hello@taylor.town
- culi 4y agoSimilarly I have a really old email account that's infested with spam. I mostly keep it around because the spam box is genuinely entertaining and I sometimes get really creative ones. The kind of spam you usually don't even find in your spam box nowadays. Like the real "Nigerian prince" classics
- vasco 4y agoI don't love them by themselves as much as you but definitely get lots of value from ads in terms of finding and buying cool things. Interestingly the internet has only learned to properly advertise to me as an individual. I have way more purchasing power from buying decisions I make in behalf of my company and in terms of corporate advertising for B2B SaaS products google and friends are leaving a lot of money on the table. Most ads I see for B2B things are for tools my company already uses.
- not_kurt_godel 4y agoSend me a dump of your email inbox and browser history and in exchange I'll send you some tailor-made ads once a week.
- Ekaros 4y agoNothing wrong with actually finding some of the adds interesting. I'm just not sure if I want the tracking and targeting. But context sensitivity is entirely fine. If I were on the site talking about sausages, meat grinder adds for example would be entirely appropriate.
- didgetmaster 4y agoThe article has several links at the bottom of the page. He forgot to include "Do not sell my personal information" in his list. That would have made the sarcasm complete!
- onurcel 4y agoI am curious what makes the author think that expert reviews are free of any incentives for abusing their influence. Also, if you ever built anything useful in your life, you should know that it's not possible to count solely on word-of-mouth, even in a upotian marketing-free world. Listen, I get you are disappointed by bad actors, but going to the other extreme is never a solution.
- surprisetalk 4y ago> I am curious what makes the author think that expert reviews are free of any incentives for abusing their influence. Author here. I definitely don't think that! The internet is swamped with annoying listicles like "100 Vacuums That Will Change Your Life in 2023". Affiliate links and SEO offer perverse incentives for expert reviewers. But word-of-mouth survives! At we speak, there is an affiliate-free product thread on the front-page of HN: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34272687 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34272687 EDIT: wrong link :)
- not_kurt_godel 4y agoThere are many in tech whose jobs rely on selling personal information in ways that users would never consent to if they were made fully aware of what was being collected, how it was being collected, and how it was being used. I can't imagine it feels good to constantly deal with the cognitive dissonance required to participate in such schemes.
- bluesign 4y agoThis is not tech specific, this is the world we live in. It is built on ignorance. - It is the steak I ate at dinner. - It is the AC I turned up in summer. - It is the car I drive etc.
- not_kurt_godel 4y agoSociety does indeed effectively force us to participate in a number of immoral systems and choices but the ones you listed are not equivalent to voluntarily choosing a job whose fundamental basis is deceiving people into violating their privacy for your personal gain.
- starwind 4y agoAgreed, there's greater sins and lesser sins and it's insane to think otherwise.
- kevinh 4y agoSome would disagree that opting into eating meat—supporting an industry that kills billions of animals each year—is better than any violation of privacy. As I'm sure you're aware, the majority of the population doesn't bat an eye at that. I don't think it's at all surprising that enough people wouldn't be bothered by some non-lethal deception for monetary gain.
- timeon 4y ago> - It is the steak I ate at dinner. - It is the AC I turned up in summer. - It is the car I drive I know that this is just example. But are these specific things common?
- Ekaros 4y agoI wonder, how much my personal information is actually worth? The stuff you have at least? And if I were to approve it for the sale, what would be my cut of that value be? As surely I deserve it?
- surprisetalk 4y agoAccording to the Equifax Data Breach Settlement Fund, it's worth $5.21: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34279700 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34279700
- scotty79 4y agoOn one hand it seems like a lot. On the other, it indicates that those companies are actually horribly bad at making use of it. Which kinda tracks.
- imiric 4y agoThere's some napkin math in this article[1]. User data is worth much, much more than the the value users extract from "free" services. Especially considering this data is sold continually and perpetually. It doesn't just get purged from the market when the user stops using the service, and it's even bought and sold if the user never signed up for the service (shadow profiles). We should definitely receive a fraction of these profits, or at the very least have control over the price and terms of sale. [1]: https://www.forbes.com/sites/forbestechcouncil/2020/10/30/should-tech-companies-be-paying-us-for-our-data/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/forbestechcouncil/2020/10/30/sh...
- eljimmy 4y agoEver since I left all social media and blocked (as much as I could) trackers in my apps and networks, I rarely see any targeted ads now. I now see completely irrelevant ads for things like stair lifts for the elderly. I quite enjoy not being targeted.