8 ms·
Safe deposit boxes aren’t safe (2019)
- zzz345345 4y agohttps://web.archive.org/web/20230103102158/https://www.nytimes.com/2019/07/19/business/safe-deposit-box-theft.html https://web.archive.org/web/20230103102158/https://www.nytim...
- aeternum 4y ago$246 annual rent in return for a potential $10M+ liability? No wonder banks are getting out of this business.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- wahern 4y agoI pay about $400/year for $1.5 million in commercial property liability insurance for a small office space. And the risk of somebody "slipping" and collecting $1.5 million is far, far more likely. Every time you drive your car or bicycle you take the risk of running over a star athlete or CEO, and facing a $10 million judgement on lost earnings. Anyhow, banks will typically require liability disclaimers from deposit box renters, so their exposure is de minimis (probably of freak incident * probability of ineffective disclaimer). I'm guessing the real reason for not wanting these deposit boxes is the same reason banks are shedding branch staff--labor is costly; and the same reason retailers spent the past few decades selling and leasing back store locations--inflate their quarterly earnings reports by dumping accumulated real estate assets.
- derefr 4y ago> labor is costly Why would one need labor to operate a safe-deposit box business? Can't you just have a very secure warehouse full of boxes, with warehouse robots that will grab those boxes and put them into a drop slot when someone taps the appropriate smart card? Before anyone says that that's impractical/too expensive: there are robotic parking garages that do this for cars, and that's a much higher OpEx.
- User23 4y ago> Why would one need labor to operate a safe-deposit box business? Because physical security boils down to capable men with guns, whether that's private security, the police, or godfather type arrangements.
- kennyloginz 4y agodrones , remote weapons, surveillance tech, “lingering weapons”, has shown that physical security absolutely does not boil down to “ capable men with guns”.
- Lio 4y ago> Because physical security boils down to capable men with guns, whether that's private security, the police, or godfather type arrangements. >> drones , remote weapons, surveillance tech, “lingering weapons”, has shown that physical security absolutely does not boil down to “ capable men with guns”. How is that disproving the parents point? Capable men with drones is not meaningfully different to capable men with guns, or pointy sticks for that matter.
- adgjlsfhk1 4y agoIf there's no human involved, what stops someone coming in with a screwdriver and hammer?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- kube-system 4y agoUnmanned storage exists already, but it is seen as less secure, because often nobody is there to monitor it. https://uploads.website.storedge.com/60281063-f09b-41fb-be8f-998d4b85315a/48281-sr-2.jpg https://uploads.website.storedge.com/60281063-f09b-41fb-be8f... The allure of a bank is that it’s a bank and it is seen as secure because of the self interest in the bank itself being secure.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- zuminator 4y agoDoubtless. Even so, the article does mention that safe deposit box insurance is available from third party providers. I don't know about the rates, but I'd imagine if anything it's probably cheaper to insure a half million dollars worth of valuables stuck in a bank vault than the same items stored in your bedroom. Although there's also the possibility of including the items in the box as part of a homeowner's insurance policy. [0] The problem being that some things people put in boxes have a sentimental value that makes them irreplaceable. You can be compensated for Grammy's brooch but it's not the same as Grammy's brooch. [0] https://www.geico.com/living/home/home-protection/safe-keeping-three-key-things-to-know-about-safe-deposit-boxes/ https://www.geico.com/living/home/home-protection/safe-keepi...
- Lio 4y ago> I'm guessing the real reason for not wanting these deposit boxes is the same reason banks are shedding branch staff--labor is costly; It's because most business schools teach business administrators to seek rent for doing nothing. Making anything, providing any service or really doing anything other than pure rent seeking is an opportunity to be beaten by those who care enough to do it better and so should be avoided. The ideal business would be one where capital is rented out for maximum return without having to think about how to get the best return. To a remote man with a spreadsheet everything has a cost and nothing has a value.
- michaelt 4y ago> It's because most business schools teach business administrators to seek rent for doing nothing. To be fair, renting out metal boxes you already own doesn't exactly sound labour-intensive.
- simonblack 4y agoThe Banks would prefer you to pay a fee so that you can donate your valuables to that Bank. If you don't control those assets, they are no longer yours. You doubt that? Just try to access that safety deposit box when that bank is closed for the night. One day that Bank will close for the night and not reopen for quite a while if at all. What will you do then?
- homero 4y agoMost of my local banks stopped opening at all. Idk if they have safety deposit boxes that can't be accessed now.
- loeg 4y ago> One day that Bank will close for the night and not reopen for quite a while if at all. Are you talking about Fridays? Or something else?
- simonblack 4y agoThere are lots of instances where Banks and/or other financial institutions close for the night 'as usual', but then never reopen. What happens to all those accounts that are never able to be accessed again by their 'owners'? Examples: Lehmann Brothers in New York, Pyramid in Australia, that Scottish bank in England some 10 years back, Barings Bank, etc, etc. And there was also the Savings and Loan fiasco in the US around 1990. Most people lost the lot, or at the very least lost a goodly proportion of their assets.
- yareally 4y ago> "What happens to all those accounts that are never able to be accessed again by their 'owners'?" It's not an issue on the United States. Many countries have similar insurance programs https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federal_Deposit_Insurance_Corporation https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federal_Deposit_Insurance_Co...
- quickthrower2 4y agoIf I go far away on holiday the assets in my home are no longer under my control.
- dang 4y agoRelated: Safe Deposit Boxes Aren’t Safe (2019) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27109002 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27109002 - May 2021 (6 comments) Safe Deposit Boxes Aren't Safe - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20545276 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20545276 - July 2019 (143 comments) Safe Deposit Boxes Aren’t Safe - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20482077 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20482077 - July 2019 (2 comments)
- metadat 4y agoIs this a second chance pool post? I could've sworn I saw it in /new yesterday, but HN search turns up nothing.
- Tomte 4y agoYes, three hours ago I was sound asleep.
- soupfordummies 4y agoThis same thing happened to me with a post a few months ago. Is that how it works?
- metadat 4y agoYes, check out /pool: https://news.ycombinator.com/lists https://news.ycombinator.com/lists
- snvzz 4y agohttps://archive.is/7qbkR https://archive.is/7qbkR
- theamk 4y agoGreat article to show to people saying "put your backup passphrase / second hardware key into the safe deposit box" Keeping physical stuff safe is hard. Banks were specifically invented so that people didn't need to keep valuables on them.
- majormajor 4y agoWhile I wouldn't put things that could single-handedly grant access in there - since you likely won't be checking on if it's been compromised that frequently - I think it's still great for things like backup 2FA codes or recovery passwords for encrypted media that's stored separately. Make breaking into the box one of the things an attacker would need to do. I would not put my life savings in jewelry or something in there, but having an off-premise spot for emergency backup codes and stuff like that? Where's a better option?
- shric 4y agoStore them in the cloud (or multiple clouds if you wish) encrypted with an extremely strong passphrase that you definitely won't forget?
- ilammy 4y agoHow do you access the cloud if you lost your laptop? Or even all of your stuff burned down along with your house? How do you remember a strong passphrase after four months in hospital recovering from a cerebral trauma? Emergency emergencies. Off-site physical backups are important too.
- shric 4y agoYou don't need to particularly safeguard the credentials to get to your encrypted blob, they can be in a gmail email you sent to your friends and/or family. They can't read the content but they can give you a copy. How do you remember where your safe deposit box is after four months in hospital recovering from a cerebral trauma? There's no perfect solution.
- version_five 4y agoWells Fargo — which in recent years has admitted to systematically ripping off customers with fake accounts, hidden fees and a variety of unwanted and unnecessary financial products — didn’t follow that law. I normally don't like the NYT and I know it continues to get worse, but we need more of this calling our bullshit plainly. I wish we had this in the Canadian media, most of our big companies (and all our banks) are criminal, better to just say so and not tiptoe around it
- twblalock 4y agoOn the contrary, I wish the media would not present Wells Fargo as a uniquely bad actor. The only difference between them and the other big banks is that Wells Fargo got caught. Reading an article like this, you might think you would be better off with BofA or Citibank or Chase, but that’s not the case. They are all the same — constrained by a banking culture and a regulatory regime that forces them to all be the same.
- jolux 4y ago> a regulatory regime Yet somehow smaller banks and credit unions don't have this problem. I've not had any issues like this with my Schwab checking account.
- twblalock 4y agoI didn’t have any issues like that with my Wells Fargo checking account either. But apparently they happened, so one person’s experience is not exactly useful here.
- Eisenstein 4y agoWhat an absurd retort. No one can prove a negative (prove your bank hasn't scammed other people), but you can prove that Wells Fargo was scamming people. You can assert anything you like, but it is not the onus of others to prove you wrong.
- scorxn 4y agoThe end of the article made me wonder: are museums insured for theft? Maybe they could offer safe deposit boxes :)
- Eleison23 4y ago[dead]
- GuB-42 4y agoBut are museums good targets? Let's say you steal a famous painting worth millions, how are you going to resell it? These are unique pieces, people will know you are selling a stolen good or a fake, no way around it. And the illegitimate owner of the painting will have a hard time enjoying it too, if you show it off, you will get a lot of unwanted attention. In the end, it is a great way of pissing off many people, probably not a great way to make money. Maybe you can steal and remelt gold items, but still, I don't think that museums make such good targets, not fungible enough ;) Safe deposit boxes on the other hand often store easy to resell valuables like cash and gold. I fact, I think it would be a terrible idea to put these in museums as it would make them more attractive targets.
- User23 4y agoWells Fargo are just assholes and have been for at least 20 years. I wouldn't generalize this to all banks.
- jdkee 4y agoThe point is there is no federal law protecting consumers of any bank.
- notpushkin 4y agoWhy there should be one? Just read your contracts.
- wutheringh 4y agoRight, no need to be bankist.
- somat 4y agoSafe deposit boxes are the cloud equivalent to having a safe, you pay someone to manage and pull security and you are saved from having to do it yourself.
- henriquez 4y ago[flagged]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- benced 4y agoThe idea that they can change the terms from the contract you signed is ridiculous. I don’t mind a liability cap for the banks but changing that under you? Insane.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- sowbug 4y agoIt's different when the contract is a lease whose original term has expired. If it were for a year, for example, perhaps both sides adhered to the contract, but after that each side might have an opportunity to renegotiate the next year-long term. Clickwrap agreements are annoying, and devilish when combined with an ongoing service.
- smaili 4y agoAre there any actual alternatives? Keeping your valuables at home or places like Public Storage aren't the safest of places either.
- dmoy 4y agoNo it's like democracy - safe deposit boxes are the worst form of security for small things, except for all the others. If you have land in the middle of nowhere you can bury shit in the ground. But that's not a realistic option for most people.
- massysett 4y agoCome to think of it though, burying it in the ground is an option even if you have a little city lot. Would have worked out a lot better for the guy in this article. It’s safe from many hazards and casual crooks. One problem is keeping it dry.
- ghaff 4y agoWaterproof boxes are pretty bombproof and you could always nest them. That said, I wouldn't have a lot of confidence burying something in an urban environment. And, even if you're out in the country someplace, it's probably best reserved for things you want to keep physically safe long-term without frequent access.
- rrrrrrrrrrrryan 4y agoBurying stuff is a decent option is there's something you want kept safe for decades, but if you want regular access to the stash, it's completely infeasible.
- ggm 4y agohttps://www.latimes.com/california/story/2022-09-30/judge-backs-fbi-beverly-hills-safe-deposit-box-raid https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2022-09-30/judge-ba... TL;DR warrantless search by government, seizure of presumed guilty until proven innocent findings.
- TedDoesntTalk 4y agoThis is unbelievable. It’s like living in a dictators regime.
- _cenw 4y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Civil_forfeiture_in_the_United_States https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Civil_forfeiture_in_the_Unit... It’s probably worse than you think.
- marcus0x62 4y agoDon’t forget parallel construction, whereby the government can lie in open court about the source and nature of their evidence. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parallel_construction https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parallel_construction
- ananonymoususer 4y agoNothing is 100% secure, but I have opted for a high-quality gun/fire safe that's bolted to the foundation of my home (in a gated community), and protected by multiple monitored alarm systems and cameras. The safe has a lot more room than any bank's box would, it's cheaper in the long-run, and IMHO (especially after reading the fine article) more secure. Also, it's got a S&G spin-dial lock that I trust a lot more than any electronic garbage.
- Wistar 4y agoWhere in the house is the safe located? I saw a video some years ago that made a fairly compelling case for locating the safe in a pantry or laundry room or anywhere other than the master bedroom, master closet, master bath or home office.
- gorgoiler 4y agoWhile it would be nice to have something that could withstand a casual burglar, the more likely threat to my stuff is a house fire. Where is the best for a safe to survive in a burning building, but also not be visible to anyone and remain thermally neutral? Fire safes are passive thermal sinks that reflect and damp heat transfer for as long as possible before ultimately turning into a giant heavy toaster oven. I wonder if active fire safes are a thing? Imagine the security of a safe but with an armored thermal pipe sticking out the top that goes to a heat sink somewhere outdoors. Kind of like AC but for precious documents / grandpa’s watch. I guess you’d want it to fuse and fall off if the pipe started piping heat into the safe.
- mint2 4y agoYou want a floor safe in your basement.
- tda 4y agoHow do you mitigate the flood risk in a basement. Sewer malfuntioning, heavy rain, but also firefighters flooding your burning house? I would think (no numbers to back it up) for most houses the risk of flooding is higher that the risk of burning down
- bikeformind 4y agoTo trust an ancient, bureaucratic, and often incompetent institution as the sacred guardian of some small amount of treasure seems highly unnecessary.
- p1esk 4y agoWho do you suggest we should trust instead?
- sam345 4y agoI can sympathize but it's odd that the article is calling for a federal law. . Shows a complete lack of research and understanding of the "United States" and the roles of the federal and state governments, or just a clear a bias toward federalizing everything. The law that governs the bank safe deposit boxes is state law. This is pure personal proprety law of bailment and has nothing to do with interstate commerce or banking. I mean you can't get much more local than keeping your personal items in a box. There's no reason to have federal law apply. Federal government does interstate commerce, national security, and a few other things relating to the country as a whole and that's it. Having federal law govern safe deposit for boxes is like saying the federal government should be policing whether parking attendendanta bang up or rob the car you leave them or restaurants should be federally liable for hat and coat checks. State law has always governed the responsibilities of the person who takes care of something you leave them. it's property law 101. The federal government has no business and no jurisdiction being involved in enforcing bailment responsibiliies or rewriting contracts. It's not lack of interest by the feds it's lack of jurisdiction. There's no interstate commerce going on in a safe deposit box. If the feds need to step in here we might as well get rid of state laws and states entirely.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- noaoh 4y agoI was thinking of putting my social security card + the master password to my bitwarden account in a safe deposit box. Good to know that's not a good idea.
- ghaff 4y agoI haven't had a physical social security card since a wallet was stolen 40+ years ago and I've never needed it. And there are various approaches to safeguarding passwords that don't involve writing it down in one place.
- Obscurity4340 4y agoJust spend a few hours making and scattering "horcruxes".
- OJFord 4y agoShamir secret sharing is a rigorous way to do it. Maybe for this purpose just spreading catenable chunks and some duplicates would be fine though. (It would 'just' mean one being discovered weakens the overall password, if the finder knows what it is. With SSS knowing any less than all of the shares doesn't reveal any part of the secret.)
- Snawoot 4y agoWell-known implementation of SSS: https://linux.die.net/man/1/ssss-split https://linux.die.net/man/1/ssss-split
- rkagerer 4y agoI've also seen reports of banks that move/consolidate branches shipping deposit box contents with couriers like UPS etc. who lose them.
- prima-facie 4y agoI used to work for a small IT company based in London on Hatton Garden a few years ago. At lunch time we used to stroll down to the food market on Leather Lane for a quick bite. It was busy like a bee hive with people working in the city and I absolutely loved it. I remember walking past all those glitzy jewelry stores on Hatton Garden and staring at the various stuff they had on display - thinking I would never want to work in that business given the risks involved. Then during the Easter bank holiday in 2015 the famous heist happened at number 88. I've never seen so many TV vans reporting from the site for weeks on end. It felt completely surreal. That event confirmed for me that concentrating so many valuables in such a small space (even if tightly guarded) is too risky. Your home could in theory be burgled but it will never be as attractive as a room full of deposit boxes.
- secfirstmd 4y agoI used to work around there. Couldn't agree more. On two different occasions over the course of a year I spotted robberies about to occur and reported them to the police. On one other occasion I spotted a surveillance team following individuals there. No way in hell would I wanna work in those stores. Not worth it.
- martyvis 4y ago>Then during the Easter bank holiday in 2015 the famous heist happened at number 88. Famous somewhere, but I hadn't heard of it. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hatton_Garden_safe_deposit_burglary?wprov=sfla1 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hatton_Garden_safe_deposit_bur...
- prima-facie 4y agoThey made a movie with Michael Caine about it: https://m.imdb.com/title/tt5789976/ https://m.imdb.com/title/tt5789976/ Not too bad
- rdevsrex 4y agoThis makes me wonder if simply burying what you have is a better option. One of my long standing goals is to buy some raw land for hunting and camping, like 50+ acres. I could easily bury several caches of valuables, that only my immediate family knows about, and let nature regrow over it. I mean, what are the chances that a rando stranger is going to be in the middle of nowhere with a metal detector?
- highwaylights 4y agoI would think the more likely threat would be that someone sees you making a deposit.
- magnusss 4y agoHaha right! Or that some ne’er-do-well tricks or coerces you into revealing your treasure’s location.
- yellow_lead 4y agoYeah, but many people have buried their money and later found it deteriorated beyond use. Make sure to use some good containers if you go that route :)
- carlosjobim 4y agoGold. Nobody buries paper money.
- yellow_lead 4y ago> Common causes of damage are fire, water damage, chemicals, explosives, damage caused by animals (including consumption of the currency) or damage from extended burying of the currency [1]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mutilated_currency https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mutilated_currency
- randerson 4y ago
- jacksgt 4y agoDoes anyone know if these "lax regulations" (e.g. no federal laws) also apply in Europe/EU/Switzerland?
- mdip 4y ago> Banks increasingly regard safe deposit boxes as more of a headache than they’re worth. They’re expensive to build, complicated to maintain and not very lucrative. I think this article answers the question as to "why". I remember about 15 years ago the bank by my house opened up and passed on an offer that people who opened one of their high-deposit checking accounts would get a Safe Deposit Box for free. At the age I was, I really had nothing of particular value to store there and it seemed like a silly thing to get but I was curious. Reading the leasing agreement, the bank made it very clear that the "Safe Deposit Box" provided far less assurance that my (non-existent) valuables would be protected than they would in a good safe in my home. The paperwork reminded me that purchasing insurance for the Safe Deposit Box[0] was a necessity and the bank would not be liable for losses. It's basically a product where the entire thing the customer wants to buy, security at the expense of convenience, is precisely what they are not selling you "despite the name". To make up for that problem, apparently, my local bank thought it'd be best to give them away to people, like me, who have no use for one. Of course it's not lucrative! People who would be willing to pay a reasonable sum of money to protect their assets aren't going to rent a Safe Deposit Box with a "your stuff will probably be there, but get insurance" guarantee. [0] Do they make Safe Deposit Box insurance or do you add those valuables to your homeowners? I never found out.
- ghaff 4y agoAs the article says, they're sort of a legacy thing. Some people may still use them for jewelry they wear to their annual gala or, as in the case described, valuable collectibles that they don't want to get rid of but don't want to keep around the house either. But historically people would have things like bearer bonds, paper stock certificates, gold coins, or just a lot of cash that they needed to put somewhere safe. And that's a lot less common these days.
- bluSCALE4 4y agoWife worked at a few banks. With so many branches closing or downsizing operations, if they decide to stop offering boxes, that means opening them up if they can't reach you.