5 ms·
Berkeley Lab scientists develop a new method of refrigeration
- dieselgate 4y agoWow don't see an article like this every day? At a wedding over the summer met someone who is a refrigeration researcher and wasn't previously aware of this topic of study, nice to gain slightly more context into the field
- scythe 4y ago>This could give us a place to use CO2 from carbon capture. You don't need ten trillion tons of ethylene carbonate for refrigerators, unfortunately. Or, um, fortunately.
- zenmacro 4y agoIf I recall correctly, reducing greenhouse gas emissions from refrigerants is one of the top opportunities highlighted in Drawdown [1]. [1] https://drawdown.org/the-book https://drawdown.org/the-book
- Cthulhu_ 4y agoAre leaky refrigerants still as big of an issue? CO2 is fairly benign, ammonia... is toxic but doesn't it break down over time? Not sure on that one. Anyway, I'm sure the combined electricity usage is a bigger issue than the refrigerants. If this (and other) technologies can help reduce that, that would be great. Mind you, there's a few things that can already be done to reduce power usage of cooling solutions; better insulated buildings (with shutters, awnings, and heat-reflecting windows), chest fridges, evaporative coolers, etc. There was a video about this clay fridge (https://mitticool.com/product/mitticool-clay-refrigerator50-liter/ https://mitticool.com/product/mitticool-clay-refrigerator50-...) that cools its contents (by 10-15 degrees compared to room temperature) just from evaporating water; analog tech like that could be used anywhere to help cool things down.
- viggity 4y agofwiw, most people know "clay fridge" by the name "zeer pot". pretty easy to DIY.
- midoridensha 4y agoFrom the article: >The first experiment showed a temperature change of 25 degrees Celsius using less than one volt, a greater temperature lift than demonstrated by other caloric technologies. This makes no sense. Voltage is not a measure of energy, it's a measure of electrical potential, or electromotive force. Low voltage with extremely high current is still a lot of energy. The only thing important with refrigeration efficiency is how much (electrical) energy it requires to achieve a certain change in thermal energy; for this, you'd need to measure the voltage and current, or just the wattage, plus measure the actual thermal energy change (usually measured in BTU for air conditioners).
- varenc 4y agoThe article is a bit confusing on that point. From looking at the paper it seems like the 1 volt is relevant not because it's supposed to be implying energy efficiency by itself, but for some other reasons I don't understand. From the abstract: > "Our experimental results show a coefficient of performance of 30% relative to Carnot and a temperature lift as high as 25°C using a voltage strength of ~0.22 volts." And from the actual paper: > "To modulate the electrochemical potential in a real system, the ion concentration can be controlled by applying a voltage in an electrolytic cell (e.g., dual-ion battery), where the applied voltage is typically ~1 V. This stimulus is considerably milder than those used in magnetic, electric, and pressure-based caloric systems." I'm not following the paper at all, but it sounds like requiring a low electrical potential is a good thing.
- StrangeDoctor 4y agoElectrolysis of water becomes extremely favorable above 1.23 volts, and is not something you want to subject most electrodes to. The closer you get to 1.23 volts the more and more likely it is for electrolysis to happen at a given current used to maintain the field they'd need. I'm not 100% on this given I don't want to buy the paper and am not an expert in this field, but have done a lot electrolysis related work on personal projects. edit: Also electroplating would probably become a concern as well depending on what exactly is in that brew.
- 4y ago
- jacob019 4y agoThe article makes it sound like it's little more than theory at this point.
- dau 4y agoThe key phrase is right in the first sentence: "could someday [...]" Usually (and especially in this case) a strong indication that reading the article is a complete waste of time.
- throwaway89201 4y agoWithout access to the paper, and only (derivatives of) obfuscating university press releases, the supplementary material [1] allows fumbling together a naive idea of what this is about. On page 13 a model system is provided with a "SI.6 Thermodynamic Analysis of Ideal Ionocaloric Cycle with Regeneration" diagram to stare at. Alternative substances to ethylene carbonate are described on page 5. Sodium iodide is selected as the salt that is needed in high concentration "to move the phase boundaries". The mechanism of regeneration seems to be electrodialysis [2], which "is used to transport salt ions from one solution through ion-exchange membranes to another solution under the influence of an applied electric potential difference", a word completely missing in TFA. There's a nice exploded view of the "Figure SI.10 Electrodialysis Experimental Setup" on page 23, after which the specific Nafion NRE-212 cation exchange membrane [3] and Fujifilm AEM Type 1 anion exchange membrane [4] are listed. The 2015 article "Present and future caloric refrigeration and heat-pump technologies" [5] is listed as reference, which gives an overview of different "caloric energy conversion" methods and states that "elastocaloric refrigeration represents the most promising alternative, and magnetocaloric refrigeration is a very promising alternative for future applications." [1] https://www.science.org/doi/suppl/10.1126/science.ade1696/suppl_file/science.ade1696_sm.pdf https://www.science.org/doi/suppl/10.1126/science.ade1696/su... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electrodialysis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electrodialysis [3] https://www.h2planet.eu/nl/detail/NafionNRE212 https://www.h2planet.eu/nl/detail/NafionNRE212 [4] https://www.fujifilm.com/nl/en/business/manufacturing-process/ion-exchange-membranes/overview https://www.fujifilm.com/nl/en/business/manufacturing-proces... [5] https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0140700715001759 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S014070071...
- at_a_remove 4y agoSo now we have the acoustic cavity, this, and that weird optical thing I read about over a decade back (I dimly recollect that it was light-activated and there was a strange glass involved). I always get a kick out of refrigeration, and I think I know why: you're straight up fighting entropy (locally of course) in one of its most raw and obvious forms. Sometimes I wonder how many basic methods there are and if they can be combined in bizarre, almost unfathomable ways.
- seiferteric 4y agoThere is also: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magnetic_refrigeration https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magnetic_refrigeration which I periodically check in on to see if their is any progress or commercialization, but so far it doesn't seem like it.
- Zecc 4y ago> I always get a kick out of refrigeration It's a cooler subject. (sorry)
- rjzzleep 4y agoOne thing I have to note and keep wondering about is whether these "Berkeley Lab scientist", "Google researcher", "Institution X" add anything of value to the actual content of the research? A publications uses to the name to add credibility, the institution itself wants its name there even if it is not associated to the research (as was the case for the "google researcher solves math problem" one), but do we really need that on HN?
- Cthulhu_ 4y agoIt does sound like a weird appeal to authority, now you mention it. Here's the actual paper with names: https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.ade1696 https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.ade1696
- stonogo 4y agoBerkeley Lab employs both authors of this paper. Berkeley Lab, and this research, gets its funding from the US Department of Energy. One of the authors is a pretty high-level manager, of the sort who drives strategic planning there. It's safe to say the institution is associated with this research. I do personally regard national lab affiliation to be a meaningful quality signal -- at least strong enough that if I'm interested in the topic I'll read the actual paper, which isn't something I can say for a lot of stuff coming out of certain universities lately. Another good reason to note the institution is that this is a demonstration that DOE Office of Science research funding is generating results.
- dotgov 4y agoThe DOE Office of Science funding is generating papers as results. If my interpretation is correct, the technology discussed is _potentially_ useful. To me the downside of marketing results aggressively to justify one’s funding is that the quality signal can become inversely correlated. Is this valuable research or is someone who knows to play the DOE game inflating a metric to secure their next round of funding and/or expand their turf? Does this negatively impact researchers who do not have access to a comparable marketing apparatus?
- semi-extrinsic 4y agoI haven't studied the new method in detail. But I will say they have an annoyingly poor understanding of the current state of vapor compression system refrigerants. Because from the technological standpoint this is a solved problem. Domestic refrigeration runs on hydrocarbons (your fridge is likely running on pentane). Supermarket refrigeration runs on CO2. Both of these have proven efficiency, safety and environmental aspects, with millions of units installed. Large commercial refrigeration (slaughterhouse etc.) runs on hydrocarbons or ammonia, the latter is of course toxic, but in a large factory you have adequate procedures to handle that safely. The two biggest challenges wrt. refrigerants today are to ensure that the old and bad solutions are phased out worldwide and not just in the richer countries, and to make sure the same transition happens for heat pumps, where the R1234-variants are being pushed now but are still problematic.
- nirolo 4y agoJust created an account to post exactly this. How such a statement could make it into the article is really baffling. Of the most efficient heatpumps in Europe, most are running on propane, which has negligible GWP ( global warming potential https://hydrocarbons21.com/ipcc-includes-gwps-for-hydrocarbons-in-new-report/ https://hydrocarbons21.com/ipcc-includes-gwps-for-hydrocarbo... ) see for example https://lambda-wp.at/ https://lambda-wp.at/ (only in German, sorry) Also, air conditioners for the private home can run on propane , see https://www.green-cooling-initiative.org/news-media/news/news-detail/2021/11/15/midea-sets-benchmark-for-more-climate-protection-with-first-r290-model-on-the-german-european-market https://www.green-cooling-initiative.org/news-media/news/new...
- stonogo 4y agoAnd here they've demonstrated an approach which uses a material that is zero GWP, non-toxic, non-hazardous, etc. I get that fridge techs are happy with the way things are, but research continues regardless.
- wolfi1 4y agohas already been discussed here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34156227 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34156227
- greenbit 4y agoHave seen half a dozen articles about this, all of them sketchy press pieces that leave me wondering. It sure would be nice to see some diagrams.
- gumby 4y agoIsn't this "ioncaloric" process the process that makes a propane flame refrigerator work? Oh, they say: > No one has successfully developed an alternative solution that makes stuff cold, works efficiently, is safe, and doesn’t hurt the environment,” OK, so a propane fridge emits GHG when it burns the propane, and ammonia is not the safest compound in the world. Got it. This work is interesting, but the claim unreasonable.