2 ms·
> congress spent nearly zero time passing any pro-choice laws. What pro-choice federal law do you imagine would have substantive effect in the face of what wou
by dragonwriter 4y ago
> congress spent nearly zero time passing any pro-choice laws.
What pro-choice federal law do you imagine would have substantive effect in the face of what would be (and was) necessary for Roe to fall:!a Supreme Court that is (1) so dismissive of well-established precedent as to strike down the cases establishing abortion as a 14th Amendment right (thereby both removing the independent bar to state anti-abortion law and removing the enforcement clause of the 14th Amendment as a basis for federal law), (2) from a faction also opposed to expansive readings of the Commerce Clause (thus rendering abortion protection grounded in the Commerce Clause unviable).
This isn’t like same-sex marriage where Congress has a separate, less factionally controversial in bounds, Constitutional grant of power (in the Full Faith and Credit clause) to act under.
- jessaustin 4y agoThrowing out a simple "states may not restrict abortion except in the following ways" federal codification passed by Congress (in e.g. 2009) would have taken a lot more justification than overruling a previous court decision. The latter was a "whoops we changed our minds" and the former would have been more of a "only one branch of government counts and legislative ain't it!" Perhaps there are five ethically bankrupt justices serving now, but I can only count three, and it would have been good to uncover the others sooner rather than later. Besides, if you truly have so little faith in our institutions (congratulations on paying attention!), why bother working with them at all? It soon will be time to do something else.