4 ms·
> A reasonable alternative strategy would be to just run the business as if the price of coffee was destined to be flat, and then place counterveiling speculati
by dpark 15y ago
> A reasonable alternative strategy would be to just run the business as if the price of coffee was destined to be flat, and then place counterveiling speculative bets. The point of those bets, however, isn't to speculate it's precisely to try to eliminate the need to speculate.
The point of speculating is to eliminate the need to speculate? What the hell? This doesn't make a bit of sense.
What Starbucks did was place a bet that coffee prices would go up. Unfortunately for them, they bet wrong. That's the risk no matter how they bet, though. If they'd bet on flat prices (no lock-in) or declining prices (the other side of the bet they actually made), the price could have gone up and they could have lost money. That's why it's called speculation. Someone speculates that the price will go one direction, and they make a bet to that effect with someone else.
- eru 15y ago> If they'd bet on flat prices (no lock-in) [...] You can buy contracts to bet specifically on flat prices. And of course you can also bet on moving prices, without committing on up or down. No bet isn't an implicit bet on flat prices.
- dpark 15y agoSure. You can bet many ways. No matter what you do, though, it's a bet and you take the risk of losing money vs any other bet you could have made. And no bet is an implicit bet. You're betting that you can get as good (flat) or better (declining) a price in the future as you can get right now by locking in.