3 ms·
How does one choose between DALL-E, Stable Diffusion, Midjourney, Bing AI Image Creator, etc.? My bias is to go with Stable Diffusion because of its open source
by xnx 4y ago
How does one choose between DALL-E, Stable Diffusion, Midjourney, Bing AI Image Creator, etc.? My bias is to go with Stable Diffusion because of its open source nature. Is there an authoritative, up-to-date, comparison of the different capabilities and outputs of these tools?
- andybak 4y agoTry them all. They all have strengths and weaknesses. I use all of them for different things (and often run a prompt across several to decide)
- practice9 4y agoStable Diffusion is the only one you can host yourself or even run locally on desktop & mobile if your hardware allows. You can train your own styles and concepts using Dreambooth method (aka fine-tuning on a very small dataset) for 1.x models, or use textual inversion / LoRA / embeddings for 2.x models. SD2 is much more difficult to fine-tune so folks have been using these alternative methods. Embeddings can represent a specific style and are easier to compose. They are storage-efficient as well (<= 1 MB if I remember correctly). DALL-E is good for surreal memes or some kinds of art. It works well for outpainting. For other use-cases it falls behind on realism and flexibility. Midjourney has come a long way and generates very aesthetically pleasing images. But it's very opinionated to allow for ease of use for new users. And it can get expensive if you need to generate many images.
- Terretta 4y agoFirst line of FAQ says Image Creator is Dall-E. For the outputs, go to each one's community showcase page, or their respective discords, or their subreddits which amount to image post feeds. You'll find, roughly, Dall-E images feel clunky, Stable Diffusion are differentiated, and Midjourney are simultaneously aesthetic and yet recognizably the same. - If you want a sketch of a thing you're thinking of, go with Dall-E. - If you want to mess around, and play with other people's models, Stable Diffusion. - If you want to role play being good at DeviantArt, MidJourney. Quite often, actual artist workflows use two of the three, for instance, start in MidJourney, then outpaint with Dall-E, or start with Dall-E, then img2img with SD.
- xnx 4y agoThank you for the summary. Amazing that these have been adopted into workflows so quickly.