3 ms·
I want to be back to piracy. Not specifically for money, but for quality subtitles : I want translations that are close to the original content, not an adaptat
by hinata08 4y ago
I want to be back to piracy. Not specifically for money, but for quality subtitles :
I want translations that are close to the original content, not an adaptation that nearly destroys its meaning.
Until a decade ago, Japanese right owners were hardly interested in broadcasting content in my area.
Fansub teams would provide subs for content as long as it wasn't licensed. (it was in order to make it available, but most of them didn't want to compete with companies who would actually develop the content).
This resulted in a range of subs, each with a different trades-off between pure translations and adaptation.
If you got a subtitle from a team that offered a close translation, you had much more meaning, but you had to understand a bit of what was going on.
We also had the opportunity to make the shows a bit of our own by discussing about its meaning and by reflecting on it, in order to write the subtitles. The we could compare subtitles and what each team understood.
Now most commercial services destroy that meaning.
They take the show away : you're just a consumer/viewer without a say (don't forget to purchase a shirt to make the show your own)
They adapt it with a lot of approximations, and remove the quirks and rudeness to make it ok for the most viewers.
(yes, shonen characters are rude, you can ride a mamachari and it's not just a bicycle on which you're an angry cyclist, -kun / -chan / -dono have a meaning, ...)
I no longer enjoy to watch anime with commercial services, that's just bland. They just want to do a western show with a Japanese show.
And since I used to be in a fansub team with the 'as long as it wasn't licensed' clause, I and don't approve of piracy, so I just no longer watch this content as much as I could.
(now US shows like South Parks feel more mature)
I find it a shame that governments went all over the place to find dichotomies to break down public services on behalf of free competition (operating train isn't maintaining rails, selling power isn't maintaining lines and power plants,...), but that you can't just purchase a license for movie and its subtitles separately.