4 ms·
I'm skeptical given the state of the art. There is way more good audio content out there than I have the time/interest to listen too and I can't believe I'm th
by ghaff 4y ago
I'm skeptical given the state of the art.
There is way more good audio content out there than I have the time/interest to listen too and I can't believe I'm that atypical. And a book is a relatively big listening time commitment. I'll happily pay a few dollars more for a good human narrator.
- rickdeckard 4y agoIndeed. But this option will only be available if a critical mass is also willing to pay a few dollars more for human narration. In times of flat-fee Audiobook platforms the pressure to bring down audiobook production costs will only increase, funding a full-fledged Audiobook production for each book will only become harder to justify. Moreover, looking at what Apple describes here, they seemingly want to establish digital narration (quality) as a metric for competition between Audiobook marketplaces, not publishers. So if this works out, the major platforms will compete on digital narration and publishers will have less incentive to actually produce an Audiobook with human narrators...
- ghaff 4y agoThat's fair and it's true of a lot of AI/ML versions of content. I still paid for human transcriptions of podcasts when I was doing them because the time needed to clean up the ML versions just wasn't a good return. But the day will certainly come when that calculus changes. I know nothing about the economics of audiobooks. And will note that there are free public domain audio books already https://librivox.org/ https://librivox.org/. But TTS will improve and, at a minimum, improved TTS will be a benefit for people who can't read for various reasons.
- rickdeckard 4y agoWell, an intent of Apple seems to be to break the price of an Audiobook into license and production cost, take control of the production using AI and pay only the publishing license, instead of having to buy the rights to sell an Audiobook as a separate work of Art (because in the end, their engine will create the work of Art from the written word). Sadly I don't see how this will make Audiobooks any better than human narration could. It's more about streaming platforms taking more control over the content and have experienced people train their proprietary TTS engine along the way. Just to avoid confusion on Librivox: They offer Audiobooks of works which are already in the public domain (so not only the Audiobook is in public domain, also the rights for the book have already expired). So it's a platform allowing people to make free narration of already-free content.
- falcolas 4y agoA couple of comments from a narrator whose worked through ACX before. First, the last few years have seen a race to the bottom for narrator rates, since during the pandemic it was recognized that it's a job that can be easily done from home, literally from anywhere in the world. Accordingly, the up-front cost for an average quality 10 hour book is only about $1,500, and can be turned around in under two weeks from a human. If you get a really good and well known narrator, it's still only about $4,000 (and you'll probably get it quicker). Also, they're going to be competing against revenue share models from Amazon/Audible, which basically means it costs the author nothing up front. Amazon's bite out of audiobook sales is absurdly high (60%), so other companies could (and are) definitely improve on that. It's mostly a fight against Audible's brand at this point. But back to AI: AI narration is going to have to compete against humans willing to do a lot of work for very little pay. I'm honestly not sure the compute and QA costs will be competitive. And frankly, even if it is cheaper, it's not as if those savings will be passed back to the customer. If you'd like to look at how little it can cost to get a human to do voiceover work, check out fiverr.com and look for voice actors and narrators.
- ghaff 4y agoThanks for the insights. That doesn't really surprise me. On the flip side, I can get high quality transcriptions for $1/minute (given good audio quality). People, even those with better than average talent at some things, just often aren't that expensive. I suspect the same is true for some of the generative AI tasks that people are all excited about--new grad English majors are pretty cheap, especially if they can be assisted by search/generative AI.
- thomasahle 4y agoI have a bunch of books on my "to read" list, that still don't have a narration. I would happily listen to an AI version as an alternative.
- sigmar 4y agoFully agree with this. I could understand TTS for quickly converting articles to audio (and of course for visually impaired ppl), but for books the current state of this tech doesn't interest me. The qualities I want from a good narrator aren't in these samples (correct emphasis within a sentence, variable pacing dependent on context). For fiction books, good narrators will change timbre and accents depending on who is speaking in the text, not clear if they tried to achieve this at all (could have potential to use a different digital voice entirely). I hope that the results from this type of production are clearly labeled as computer generated in the store. I don't think putting "AB Apple Books" is clear or sufficient, for someone that doesn't know about this tech "AB" sort of looks like a placeholder for some unnamed human.
- rockemsockem 4y agoI tend to agree for the current product that Apple is releasing. IMO this technology starts to get interesting for books once folks can generate audiobooks for titles that do not have an audiobook (and likely never will due to publisher disinterest). When I first got into audiobooks I wanted to go back and listen to one of my favorite books and it wasn't available :/. I also see certain audiobooks described as "unlistenable" because of something the reader does.
- troupe 4y agoI often find books I want to read that don't have audio versions or the audio version is for a different translation than what I want to read. So if you are looking for specific things to read the (eventual) use of this type of technology to open up some of those in audio format seems useful. (But totally agree with you that this isn't going to replace a good human narrator.)