3 ms·
> The focus is clearly on "getting the grant". And the grant acts as an entity in itself, as it becomes a line in the CV of scientists, which will help them "ge
by TeMPOraL 4y ago
> The focus is clearly on "getting the grant". And the grant acts as an entity in itself, as it becomes a line in the CV of scientists, which will help them "get the next grant". The outcome of the grant becomes thus irrelevant. Maybe competition is missing?
I think there's plenty enough of competition in academia. And competition alone doesn't help, because the metrics over which one loses or wins the race are not correlated with short or long-term worthiness. And while we can describe, even if somewhat vaguely, what makes worthy science, there's no way I know of to have a stable system in which that metric drives funding.
> Deepmind keeps seeking to publish proprietary research in Nature, instead of creating an open ecosystem that will drive reinforcement-learning science forward
This research at least has some feedback: Google funds it because it expects to make money off using its results in practice, so the research has to be at least somewhat correlated with reality. Unfortunately, this structure also means that "open ecosystem" isn't pursued.