3 ms·
This is just yet another example of why taxis should be deregulated. The reason Uber is as expensive as it is is that it there are too few cars. On New Years e
by tomjen3 15y ago
This is just yet another example of why taxis should be deregulated.
The reason Uber is as expensive as it is is that it there are too few cars. On New Years eve more people want to take a cap but there is no way to increase supply, because there are too few medallions.
- mikeash 15y agoIsn't the whole point of Uber that by requiring you to book a ride using their app, they're not classified as taxis and therefore sidestep all of the associated regulation?
- adamjernst 15y agoThe cars they hire are still regulated as non-street-hail transportation--a livery cab in NYC, for example.
- mikeash 15y agoInteresting, it seems that the relevant regulations are wonderfully complex. Are such cars still limited in number? I tried to dive into the NYC taxi commission to see, but got lost pretty quickly....
- mikeryan 15y agoI can also read this article as a reason why Uber should be regulated more like cabs so folks don't get stuck with a $67 dollar cab ride for going less then a mile. In fact in Uber's unregulated market there were still too few cars on the road and it lead to artificially high prices it seems like this article is arguing for regulation.
- tomjen3 15y agoYou could argue that Uber didn't make it obvious what the price would be, which might make them liable. But in general these people didn't pay to drive a mile but to drive a mile on the busiest day of the year. That costs. The alternative -- and the reason people didn't use regular cabs -- is that there aren't enough of them. So either you get shortages or you get higher prices (which are good, since they incentivice those who don't value the transportation as much to walk).
- teyc 15y agoThere are not enough roads in the city on NYE for everyone who'd want a private car. More medallions are not going to solve this class of "spiky demand" problems. In Brisbane city on NYE, the public bus service was free after 9pm. There were a lot of road closures and people who wanted to travel to the city used public transport. I had my first bus trip of 2011 on NYE, and it was quick, because there weren't many cars on the road.