2 ms·
Vaccines don’t have long term side effects. They have short term side effects. And if they did have long term side effects, we’d observe them in the trials bec
by astrange 4y ago
Vaccines don’t have long term side effects. They have short term side effects.
And if they did have long term side effects, we’d observe them in the trials because they’d occur in the short term at a low probability.
- ifyoubuildit 4y agoIsn't the goal of a vaccine to induce a long term side effect? I'm no doctor, but why would a long term side effect necessarily manifest itself in the short term? That seems like a non-obvious conclusion.
- astrange 4y ago> Isn't the goal of a vaccine to induce a long term side effect? No, long-term means something we can’t detect for a few years. You can detect vaccine effectiveness right away. Especially in a pandemic when it’s easy to get challenged.
- ifyoubuildit 4y agoHow does that square with this though? > And if they did have long term side effects, we’d observe them in the trials because they’d occur in the short term at a low probability.
- astrange 4y agoThat's biology. It's not like we're dealing with robots with little timers in them here. They'd be "long term" side effects simply because they're so rare it'd take years to observe one. So, if you carefully watch a very large population, you'd find them sooner. Taleb: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gAlHjWctpLw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gAlHjWctpLw
- ifyoubuildit 4y agoWhat about something like cancer? If you get diagnosed with some form of cancer tomorrow, it's probably not because some cell first mutated yesterday, right? That would essentially be a "robot with a little timer". And it's just the only one a layman like myself can come up with off the cuff. I have to assume there are more. Edit: I watched the video, and this guy is presumably much smarter than I am, so I wouldn't be surprised if I'm missing something, but it doesn't seem very convincing. He's basically just claiming what you said, that conditions that take an extended amount of time to manifest just dont exist. That in some portion of the population, those conditions will necessarily manifest quickly. The video doesnt explain why I should believe that other than saying something like "these things are possible, but very unlikely".
- komali2 4y agoIDK if dude is smarter than you are, but he's a domain expert. He knows enough about the subject that it would likely take you something in the range of a decade of dedicated time, research, engagement, and experience to reach an equivalence. You're probably quite capable of this, if you decide to go down this path. If you don't want to go down this path, though, know that it probably will just take that breadth of experience to develop the understanding and intuition necessary to be able to say and explain things on the subject with confidence. You should believe it because you trust people like the one in the video when they tell you it's a good idea to clean your wounds to prevent infection. You vaguely understand this has something to do with germs, but you (probably) don't know all about the various actual diseases that cause open wound infections, their outcomes, their treatments, the history of research behind it, etc. It's an entire field of medicine, actually. Luckily for you, a lot of the important stuff can be condensed into a single important general-action for the populations: clean your wound with soap and water, then, cover it with a bandage. So why do you trust domain experts when they tell you about first aid, and not what they tell you about hugely more complex subjects, such as vaccinations and drug trials? Why the sudden skepticism now? During a pandemic, of all times? If this was a movie, the climax / resolution would be the development of a vaccine - thank god, the experts delivered us from this terror. What were you expecting instead? 10 years of lockdown while we wait for things to shake out?