4 ms·
Here are simpler definitions I think: An AI system is General and “adult” level if it can improve its own performance on some task without human support to be
by vlovich123 4y ago
Here are simpler definitions I think:
An AI system is General and “adult” level if it can improve its own performance on some task without human support to be taught how to do that. In other words, can it correctly decide when it needs practice (skill acquisition) vs knowledge acquisition (filling information gaps) on its own and figure out how to acquire that (or make clear, explicit, detailed, requests for what it needs from a human and maybe negotiate alternatives if the first ask isn’t available). Right now at best we have “baby” AI where we half to spoon feed it everything and the result is coherent but nonsensical speech. Even if we made it sensical though, that would fail the generality piece unless the AI could guide the human on what could be done to make it better (and level above that would be the AI exploring doing that on its own).
Can it correctly distinguish knowledge learned vs verified and figure out when learned knowledge should be ideally be verified to double-check the quality of the knowledge. In other words, can it acquire a skill it wasn’t programmed for from scratch without losing its ability to perform similarly on other tasks?
An example of a concrete problem would be can it go and analyze a bunch of academic papers looking for obvious fraud but also find when an entire field is based on unreproduced and shaky/conflicting results?
Of course, “AGI-Hard” problems can be solved in one of two ways. Humans building more and more capable AI systems that can chip away at problems or AGI systems building more general, smarter, faster AI systems. The whole dream of the singularity is that we build the latter because that basically builds a second intelligent life form we can converse with on some level (although of course we likely won’t be able to understand anything it tries to explain to us that’s sufficiently complex for the same reason humans can’t understand the chess moves that AI engines are making anymore).
- tlb 4y agoAny reinforcement learning system meets your first definition. RL systems don’t typically use separate practice sessions, though you could create one that did. But the need for deliberate practice maybe be just a biological brain thing. Instead, RL systems usually have a parameter for how much to explore new options vs. taking what seems to be the best. This lets them learn continuously as they go.
- vlovich123 4y agoRL systems lack the autonomy aspect I lay out in terms of finding new problems, figuring out how to improve on the task, or communicating that information in any way. What your describe is necessary but not sufficient.