3 ms·
(a) Last time America was a Manufacturing Superpower, it was because all the competition had bombed itself to rubble, twice in the same century. I don't see int
by 082349872349872 4y ago
(a) Last time America was a Manufacturing Superpower, it was because all the competition had bombed itself to rubble, twice in the same century. I don't see internal volition recreating the external conditions forged during 1914-1945.
(b) When the Plaza Accords were decided, they only needed G5 buy in to execute. To do something similar today (because the G5 is proportionally much smaller) would take buy in from nearly the entire G20. (and in the specific case of Germany: it is already reunited, so someone would have to come up with a new carrot)
(c) China needs a Belt and Road, because it needs an alternative export path to ocean shipping lanes which the US Navy can choke at will. The US has a Navy (as well as sundry client oil states to supply its Navy's logistical tail); it might be interested in a Belt and Road but definitely does not need one in the same way.
- eternalban 4y agoA few comments: (a) America and Germany were both unmatched industrial powers from late 19th century. Two world wars later and US emerged as the sole industrial power. The article is arguing for US to rejoin the industrial powerhouse set. (b) V. V. Putin and "partners" have set into motion a sort of historic locomotive. So far the thing has arrived if not departed from the station of 'burning bridges for EU'. If you read the article, it notes that Germany had prudently applied a two pronged approach for dealing with globalization: retaining component level (parts) manufacturing, and comprehensively (re)training its workforce for a new economic regime. What the article doesn't mention (though hints at by recalling Angela M's "we still make things" remark to an apparently confused Tony Blair) is the third prong of what was actually a trident: an energy 'stream' that did not require the services (or good graces) of United States Navy and client friends. That prong is gone now, and higher energy costs coupled with "Plaza Accord" type of "negotiations" (a scene from Godfather comes to mind) they enable, should make for a responsive set of allies. That said, the article advised negotiations with the Chinese, which does not compute on my end (unless the author is privy to information not available to the general public). (c)above
- 082349872349872 4y agoFair enough, if I understand your position on (b) and (c) correctly it is that while there may not be much carrot in evidence, there remains plenty of stick? Just a note as to (a): my understanding is that had Germany avoided 1914 and its sequelae, it would've (purely by extrapolation of existing growth curves and ignoring the chances that the UK would've turned from benign opposition ["Made In Britain"] to malicious [the Royal Navy having been, pre-Suez, what the USN is now]) peacefully passed the Empire in manufacturing over the course of the XX. My parenthetical reservations apart, historians' consensus take on the why of 1914 boils down to "people are stupid". [Edit: my memory tells me that the US accounted for ~50% of global manufacturing in 1960 (down from some huge percentage in 1948!). This number is amazingly difficult to confirm (the unpaywalled net being very biased towards recent time series), but if one compares to the 2015 figures of Table 1 in https://www.brookings.edu/research/global-manufacturing-scorecard-how-the-us-compares-to-18-other-nations/ https://www.brookings.edu/research/global-manufacturing-scor... , if the US wished to return to its golden age, it would have to somehow replace not only China (20%) but also all of either Japan (10%) or Germany+France (7+3%). Assuming the Chinese are unlikely to follow voluntarily in such a scenario, it would take total replacement of Japan+Germany+South Korea+India+France+Italy+UK for the US to, from its current 18%, hit 50%] Edit2: the previous Edit pretty much just recapitulates https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34254640 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34254640
- eternalban 4y ago(re "stupid" and US industrial decline before -Sputnik- event: read Gods of Money.) > Fair enough, if I understand your position on (b) and (c) correctly it is that while there may not be much carrot in evidence, there remains plenty of stick? Not my "position" - just observation. It seems to me a sort of super block fragmentation is over the time horizon. B.E. -> A.E. -> Oceania. Maybe the carrot bit is membership.
- 082349872349872 4y agoThanks for the GoM rec*. I count Brexit as having already established Oceania (it having marked Airstrip One's independence from Eurasia). * cool, this totally ties into my other hobby (online radicalisation): http://www.williamengdahl.com http://www.williamengdahl.com