5 ms·
You seem to be missing the point of the article, which is this: > the great majority of users are oblivious of the detection and remediation of malware on thei
by lapcat 4y ago
You seem to be missing the point of the article, which is this:
> the great majority of users are oblivious of the detection and remediation of malware on their Macs, which occurs in complete secrecy
This is a problem that Apple could solve but chooses not to. Everything the author is doing is admittedly a poor workaround for Apple's lack of user notification.
- hermitdev 4y agoThey probably also don't want to expose it to users at all because of marketing. Anyone remember those old ads of PC vs Mac and Mac not getting viruses? Because, I do...
- rudyfink 4y agoHere they are: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V0feR5grSa4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V0feR5grSa4 (32 second spot) / https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VEVjILqU3pU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VEVjILqU3pU (apparently the UK version of the same commercial).
- sunshinerag 4y agoThere is a difference between virus and malware no?
- b0afc375b5 4y agoColloquially? I don't think so.
- Twisell 4y agoWhen asked about that by the colloquial layman my answer is generally : Virus can self execute, replicate and spread (like biological ones) while malware (layman also refer to troyans) need user actions and unawareness to execute. Am I totally wrong?
- clnq 4y agoMalware also broadly refers to software unwanted by and malicious to the user. So it includes pre-installed auto-executing OEM adware, spyware, and grayware (colloquially also known as bloat).
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Twisell 4y agoInteresting so yeah while distinction between virus and trojan can hold, I guess that virus enter the broad malware definition and thus the OP is right.
- alwillis 4y ago> They probably also don't want to expose it to users at all because of marketing. It's incredibly intellectually lazy to suggest 'marketing'. Apple's ideology has always been that regular, everyday computer users shouldn't have to concern themselves with low-level details of system administration in order to write a book or edit a video or whatever it is they're doing. In addition, unless they have some breakthrough, elegant or innovative way of addressing stuff, they leave it to 3rd-party developers. It's also myopic to complain about something as low-level as malware remediation while glossing over the fact that Apple enabled end-to-end encryption for iCloud [1] and gave users who aren't system administrators or security experts the ability to protect themselves if they are the target of a state level attacker [2]. Addressing security/privacy at this level is a very Apple thing to do. In my opinion, it should be a no-brainer: end-to-end encryption and protection from state-level attackers vs a widget that alerts me the OS zapped a malware download. As far as malware on macOS goes, having the operating system deal with this unbeknown to the user is actually a good thing for those everyday, regular users, who would probably screw things up worse if they had to play some direct role in this. BUT for system administrators, developers and power users, the APIs and command line tools are there for them to get into the weeds of malware remediation if they want to. [1]: https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2022/12/apple-advances-user-security-with-powerful-new-data-protections/ https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2022/12/apple-advances-user-s... [2]: https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2022/07/apple-expands-commitment-to-protect-users-from-mercenary-spyware/ https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2022/07/apple-expands-commitm...
- aflag 4y agoBeing infected with malware is, hopefully, a rare event. I think it's reasonable to alert the user they've got it, even a non techy user knows roughly what those are. If they know about it they may have an idea of how they got it (they may have let someone else use their laptop or maybe received an email from someone new), which can be useful so they don't get more malware. If you really want an innovative way of doing it is trying to give the user a good track record so they know exactly where that came from.
- hellweaver666 4y ago
- nottorp 4y agoWould you like Mac OS to work like your average Windows antivirus which keeps bombarding you with notifications that FIFTY THREATS HAVE BEEN DETECTED! BE AFRAID! ?
- saagarjha 4y agoI don’t appreciate this being called “complete secrecy”. There’s literally API to find out when it happens! If it was just logged somewhere I might agree but this is just not true. Nobody says the system firewall runs in “complete secrecy” either even though it doesn’t warn you when it blocks connections. I mean, in a perfect world all of this would be perfectly exposed to users and they would know every single action their computer takes. I don’t actually disagree that putting in some effort to better surface how XProtect works could be valuable. But the current situation is generally fine and the accusations that Apple is trying to hide this stuff from you do not seem well supported.
- lapcat 4y ago> I don’t appreciate this being called “complete secrecy”. There’s literally API to find out when it happens! You still seem to be missing the point. This is about end users not developers. This is a UI problem, not an API problem. You want to make a technical point, because you're a technical person, but you're missing the forest for the trees, because this isn't a particularly technical problem. This is a typical Apple problem of paternalism, Apple believing that Apple should take care of everything, and users shouldn't worry their pretty little heads about anything. > I mean, in a perfect world all of this would be perfectly exposed to users and they would know every single action their computer takes. We're not talking about "every single action", we're talking about the OS detecting malware on an end user's Mac and then... not bothering to tell them about this fact. Imagine if you went to the doctor for a physical, took some tests, the tests indicated you had an STD, and then... the doctor just gave you some drugs and didn't bother to tell you that you had an STD. That would be malpractice. You'd want to know. You'd need to know. Because one doesn't just "randomly get" either an STD or malware. How you got it (and especially who you got it from) is just as important as that you got it. > Nobody says the system firewall runs in “complete secrecy” either even though it doesn’t warn you when it blocks connections. 1) You have to manually enable the firewall. It's disabled by default on macOS. 2) Unlike malware, you can just "randomly get" connection attempts from the internet. Attackers are probing everything. I can see that in my web server logs. I make a simple claim: if macOS takes action to remediate malware then it ought to tell the user. Simple question: Do you agree or disagree with that claim? All of the discussion about logging and endpoint security is because the author has determined in testing that macOS actually fails to tell the user when it remediates malware. To follow my earlier analogy, this is like talking about how to do your own STD tests when your doctor neglects to tell you whether you got an STD. But you doctor should really tell you, and then you wouldn't need your own tests. But you seem overly focused on the tests rather than the telling.