2 ms·
The difference between factionalization in a two-party system and in a multiparty system is, outside of aberrant situations like those in a realignment [0], it
by dragonwriter 4y ago
The difference between factionalization in a two-party system and in a multiparty system is, outside of aberrant situations like those in a realignment [0], it is virtually impossible to form crossparty coalitions in a two--party system, meaning that close division can empower small extreme ideological factions more than would be the case in a multiparty system, since the larger factions hae less choice in who to form a coalition with.
[0] which people, especially older people, in the US today might mistake for a normal condition, because the US spent about 60 years starting in the 1930s in an unusually long, overlapping set of realignments, during which the major parties were overlapping in policy preferences and each was ideologically incoherent.
- jfengel 4y agoA multiparty system also has long-term coalitions that don't realign very often. The UK has prominent parties aside from the top two, but they are nearly all in permanent alignments with one party or the other. They do provide a mechanism for those realignments when they do happen. The Tories only needed to convince LibDem leadership to join a coalition with them in 2007, rather than pulling members individually. That realignment was not successful, and it nearly wiped out the party. As you note, parties and coalitions-of-parties tend to reach ideological coherence and stay there. They all depend on long-term horse-trades that last between legislative sessions. Anybody who jumps parties (either individually or as a group) will be regarded with suspicion for a long time: they don't have a history of deals, and in fact are known to be untrustworthy. Any realignment usually starts with a deadweight loss. In the LibDem's case, it was voting for a new Prime Minister in exchange for a referendum -- one which received little support and failed badly. They were taken advantage of, and they should have known they were being taken advantage of. (The architect of that is now Vice-President for Global Affairs and Communications at Facebook, for what that's worth) So a multi-party system does present opportunities, for realignments, but in a mature system they still don't happen all that often. The network of deals is self-reinforcing and hard to restructure. This case is a little unusual in that there is a set of people who are effectively un-aligned. They don't really have any goals except the disruption of government. They're elected in alignment with a party who uses a lot of anti-government rhetoric, but they don't have any real goals in governing. They're perfectly content to let the Speaker's chair be empty, and there's not much you can offer them.