3 ms·
> One of the worst examples: "number sentence". It means what you, an adult, might guess it does (well, it means one of the things you might guess it means Spe
by dragonwriter 4y ago
> One of the worst examples: "number sentence". It means what you, an adult, might guess it does (well, it means one of the things you might guess it means
Specifically, it means “equation or inequality”.
> They don't really act like sentences or serve the same purpose.
They act exactly like sentences, and serve exactly the same purpose, because they are declarative sentences about the relationships between numbers.
> It's misleading as hell land the kids don't even have the context that might, even hypothetically, make it useful for scaffolding, when they introduce it in kindergarten.
The idea is that they are mutually reinforcing, not sequential, concepts.
It also, as a sibling comment notes, has nothing to do with Common Core, its an orthogonal development in pedagogical approach to the Common Core standards.
> The "show 5 different ways how you could have solved this" worksheets
... also have less to do with the Common Core standards thablazy development of the particular materials (demonstrating proficiency with different articulations of operations and ways of solving problems is part of Common Core, to an extent, but even where it is doing it by using them all on the same problem, in the same assignment, and doing that for a substantial number of problems on one assignment, is just bad exercise design.)
> To illustrate by example
What you offer there is an analogy, not an example. Analogies don't really act like examples and don’t serve the same purpose.
- yamtaddle 4y ago> They act exactly like sentences, and serve exactly the same purpose, because they are declarative sentences about the relationships between numbers. "Exactly" is simply incorrect in both occurrences, here. > It also, as a sibling comment notes, has nothing to do with Common Core, its an orthogonal development in pedagogical approach to the Common Core standards. All this hit alongside Common Core. Ask teachers and they won't quibble with lumping this practice in with Common Core, since that's how it's expressed in practice, though some might be aware that it's not in the standards. Source: I know a lot of teachers. > What you offer there is an analogy, not an example. It's both, so you're technically wrong, which I gather you think is the worst kind of wrong. Analogy's probably the better word here, though, sure, if I was only going to use one. > Analogies don't really act like examples and don’t serve the same purpose. They act exactly like them. Using your sense of "exactly" from above.